Laser architecturing: materials, stiffness and cracks¶
A literature survey for the architectures at the scale of the spot: which materials a local laser treatment turns into two-phase sheets, whether it can change Young’s modulus, how local property gradients steer and blunt ductile cracks, and the state of the art.
Literature survey, 8 November 2026. Scope: through-thickness treatment of 0.5–2 mm sheets with one beam or two aligned beams, smallest treated feature ≈1 mm × 1 mm, sheets up to several tens of centimetres. Every reference was found during this search. [nv] marks an item that could not be fully verified (author list, volume or value read from a secondary record). “Estimate” marks an order-of-magnitude calculation of this survey, not a literature value.
Starting point (PIMM): Wang’s thesis [1] and papers [2, 3]. Note on [2]: Mater. Sci. Eng. A 831, 142205 is the AISI 430 study (laser hardening and laser-assisted carburizing; fully multi-track treated samples gain +60% in yield stress and +45.8% in UTS). The corrugated martensite tracks in ductile ferritic steel are reported in [3].
1. Materials and treatments with a large through-thickness contrast (Q1)¶
Table 1. Property contrast obtained by local laser (or local short-time) treatment.
Material / treatment |
Contrast reported |
Thickness, process window, risks |
Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|
C–Mn–B steel (22MnB5, ≈0.22 C; same family as MS1500), annealed ferrite–pearlite, laser austenitization and self-quench |
F–P: YS 404, UTS 594 MPa, Ag 14.2%; martensite: YS 1160, UTS 1523 MPa, Ag 4.8% (×2.9 in YS, ×2.6 in UTS). Laser tracks in 22MnB5 tubes: UTS > 1.2 GPa |
2.7 mm tubes patterned with a 400 W fibre laser at 2.5 mm/s (treated depth not stated in the text read) [7]; close-type patterns (0°, auxetic, honeycomb) raise sheet strength and bending resistance [6]. Risks: hardenability for self-quench, brittle tracks, re-tempering at overlaps, distortion |
[4, 6, 7] |
Press-hardened 22MnB5, laser tempering (soft zones) |
1160/1523 → 872/920 MPa (330 HV1, peak ≈600 °C); essential work of fracture w_e: martensite 38, laser-tempered 130, bainite 124, F–P 212 kJ/m²; pre-cooled (bainitic) soft spots 260 HV5 vs 470 HV5 in the hardened sheet |
6.2 mm sheet softened homogeneously (1.92 kW on 40 × 40 mm) but with a ≈20 mm transition [4]; diode-laser softening homogeneous through thickness up to ≈1 m/min with a top-hat beam, faster with adapted intensity [9] |
[4, 5, 9] |
Low-carbon structural steel (0.18 C), pulsed Nd:YAG tracks |
≈130 → 200 HV, hardened depth 0.35 mm in 2 mm plate |
Surface only: hardenability too low for through-thickness martensite |
[10] |
DP450–DP980, martensitic steels (> 80% martensite): laser tempering or re-austenitization |
Subcritical HAZ softening only −7 HV (DP450), −18 HV (DP600), −50 HV (DP980); peaks near Ac3 give a large ductility gain with strength loss |
Softening proportional to martensite fraction, complete for time constants ≈2–3 s at Ac1 [11]; galvanised sheets treated over 1 cm wide zones, 620–1350 K [12] |
[11, 12] |
TRIP, Q&P, medium-Mn steels |
No laser architecturing study found |
Inference: medium-Mn reversion needs Mn partitioning during minutes to hours of intercritical annealing; a laser cycle on Q&P would temper martensite and destabilize retained austenite |
– |
Metastable austenitic 301/301LN/304, cold rolled then laser reversion annealing |
Full hard 301: YS ≥ 965, UTS ≥ 1275 MPa, A ≥ 9%; annealed: 205/515 MPa, 40% [13]. Reverted 301/301LN: YS typically 700–1000 MPa; complete reversion at 800 °C for 1 s: YS 800–950 MPa, TE ≈43% [15]. Laser reversion refines grains, raises strength, restores formability (+14% and +19% cup depth) [16, 17]; laser-patterned 304 stripes outperform homogeneous UFG and CG references [18] |
Window 700–1000 °C for 1–100 s after 45–78% cold rolling [14], matching laser dwell times; no quench needed. Magnetic contrast: α′ ferromagnetic, reverted γ paramagnetic; laser-written non-magnetic marks ≈350 µm wide, ≈200 µm deep in 304L [19]. Risks: α′ re-forms by TRIP under load, grain growth at high peak temperature, strong texture [14] |
[13–19] |
Ferritic Fe–Cr laminate, masked solution nitriding to austenite (GE, furnace) |
Local magnetic / non-magnetic regions; non-magnetic regions ≈2× the tensile strength of magnetic ones [nv] |
Motor laminations; not laser, but the same idea of a treated phase |
[20] |
Fe–Ni–C martensite with laser-reverted austenite lines (model alloy) |
Uniform elongation above reference martensite, UTS above reference austenite |
Heating rates up to 25 000 K/s; laser parameters and thickness control the affected zone |
[21, 22] |
Maraging 300 |
Solution annealed: YS ≈830, UTS ≈1030 MPa, 16%, 30 HRC; aged 482 °C/3 h: YS ≈1930, UTS ≈2000 MPa, 8%, 52 HRC |
Peak ageing at 480 °C takes 500–1000 min [24]: only local re-solution of aged sheet (soft tracks) is laser-compatible; no sheet study found; reverted austenite forms on ageing of laser-processed material [24]; in-situ precipitation by repeated laser cycles shown in AM (Fe19Ni5Ti, 1300 MPa, 10%) [25] |
[23–25] |
Al 6xxx T4 (6016, 6181, 6082), short-time laser heating (tailor heat treated blanks) |
Local softening by cluster dissolution; drawing depth of complex parts up to +86% (Geiger et al., as cited in [29]) |
Furnace-type windows of 500–540 °C and > 30 s, below 1 s reported by Geiger and Merklein (as reviewed in [28]); natural ageing re-hardens the soft zones and limits the gain [28] |
[26–29] |
Al 6xxx T6 (6063, 6082), laser overageing |
6063-T6, 2 mm: −32% hardness at 400 °C; −34% YS, −31% UTS at 425 °C |
Stable (no re-ageing); softened zone ≈5 mm from track centre |
[28] |
AA7075-T6, laser retrogression at ≈400 °C |
72 HB 15 min after treatment; re-hardening after 10 h, 108 HB after 10 days |
Distortion from thermal stresses, sheets cannot be clamped under optical heating [29]; joining needs ≥ 300 °C [30]; alternative: laser evaporation of Zn and Mg for local ductility [31] |
[29–31] |
AA2024-T3 |
Laser heating lines: hardness −20% at most, tensile strength −3%; tensile residual stress 160–180 MPa in the lines, compression between them; fatigue crack growth life +285% |
2 mm sheet. Low strength contrast because T3 is already naturally aged and re-ages; fusion causes solidification and liquation cracking [33]; the useful laser effect is residual stress |
[32, 33] |
Metastable β Ti-15V-3Cr-3Sn-3Al strip |
Solution treated: YS 770, UTS 790 MPa, 22%, E 82 GPa [35]; aged 482–538 °C, 8–16 h: YS 965–1172, UTS 1000–1241 MPa, 5–7%, E 107–111 GPa [34] |
Strip 0.4–2.4 mm, β transus 750–770 °C, solution 3–20 min at 790 °C [34]; thermal conductivity ≈8 W/m K [35]. Laser route: local re-solution of aged strip (kinetics at laser time scales not documented). Risks: O pick-up, ω in the heat-affected zone |
[34, 35] |
β-type Ti, laser surface solution treatment then ageing |
490–500 HV case ≈1 mm deep over a 260 HV core after ageing at 300 °C |
Laser zone ages faster; ageing still in a furnace |
[36] |
Aged β-Ti, laser surface melting or heating |
Melted layer fully β: lower stiffness and hardness; without melting, Ti-8Mo layer less stiff, Ti-30Nb-1Fe forms ω on cooling (modulus kept, hardness up) |
Stiffness and hardness gradients; ω control decisive |
[37, 38] |
Ti-5Al-5Mo-5V-1Cr-1Fe, laser remelting then 500 °C holding |
ω-assisted α precipitation, hardness rises with holding time, ω dissolved after 10 min |
Furnace post-treatment |
[39] |
Ti-6Al-4V, solid-state laser transformation hardening |
Surface hardness +≈40%, case > 2.5 mm |
Poor hardenability (α′ fraction) limits contrast |
[40] |
Ti-6Al-4V, laser gas nitriding |
1142 vs 260 HV; layer nanohardness 9.74 vs 4.10 GPa (bulk) |
Melted layer of tens to hundreds of µm, not through-thickness; cracks in nitrided layers |
[41, 42] |
NiTi strip (0.37 mm), pulsed Nd:YAG Ni vaporization (“multiple memory”) |
Ni 50.07 → 48.36 at.% after 5 pulses; Ms raised up to ≈65 °C; processed zones martensitic at room temperature, base austenitic (1 at.% Ni ≈ 80–100 K) |
0.6–0.9 kW, 1–30 ms pulses, full penetration; weld-like surface; Ti2Ni if over-processed |
[43] |
Cold-worked NiTi, local laser annealing |
Shape memory regions inside an elastic (cold-worked) matrix [44]; through-thickness gradient by surface anneal, two opposite shape changes on one heating [45]; repeated passes give a 126.7 °C transformation interval [46] |
Thin strips; functional rather than strength contrast |
[44–46] |
Cu–2Be (C17200) strip |
Solution annealed TB00 410–540 MPa vs aged TF00 1130–1350 MPa (×2.5) |
No laser study found. Inference: ageing takes hours, so only local re-solution of aged strip fits laser times; high reflectivity and diffusivity; Be fume hazard if melting |
[47] |
Mg AZ31B, laser surface melting |
Melted layer up to 140% of substrate hardness |
Surface only; corrosion resistance decreases |
[48] |
Synthesis. The large through-thickness contrasts come from transformations that complete within a laser dwell: martensite in hardenable C–Mn–B steels (×2.6–2.9 in strength, with the reverse contrast in ductility and fracture work), reversion of strain-induced martensite in cold-rolled metastable austenitic steels (YS from ≥ 965 MPa down to 300–1000 MPa depending on peak temperature, elongation 9% → ≈40%, plus a magnetic contrast), and composition or anneal changes in NiTi (functional contrast). Precipitation-hardened alloys (Al, maraging, Cu–Be, β-Ti) show large furnace contrasts, but ageing takes hours: a laser can only dissolve, hence soften, locally. In Al alloys the dissolved state re-ages at room temperature (7075 within 10 h [29], 6xxx T4 through natural ageing [28]) and T6 overageing is stable but limited to ≈−30–35%. AA2024-T3 combines the drawbacks: little to dissolve beyond natural-ageing clusters that re-form, modest overageing (≤20% hardness loss), hot cracking on melting and high diffusivity; its documented laser benefit is residual stress for crack retardation [32]. For thickness, the relevant time is the diffusion time across the (half) thickness, L²/4a: for L = 1 mm, ≈0.04 s in steel, ≈0.08 s in Ti-15-3, ≈0.004 s in Al (estimate). Steels, Ti and NiTi therefore keep features of ≈1 mm with through-thickness treatment, while Al and Cu spread heat laterally as fast as through the thickness, consistent with the ≈5 mm softened zones reported in 6063 [28]. Double-sided heating halves L and divides this time by four.
2. Can a local laser treatment change Young’s modulus? (Q2)¶
Table 2. Young’s modulus of phases and laser-treated states.
System |
Values |
Notes |
Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|
Ferrite–pearlite vs martensite (SAE 1050) |
Martensite E 3.2% lower, G 3.6% lower |
Resonant ultrasound; α-iron 0.6–1.3% above F–P |
[49] |
Austenitic vs ferritic stainless steel |
Most austenitic grades 193–200 GPa (301 ≈193), ferritic ≈200 GPa |
γ ↔ α′ changes E by a few % |
[50] |
Texture in steel sheet |
“High Young’s modulus” sheet: ≥ 205 GPa (RD, 45°), ≥ 220 GPa (TD) by γ-fibre texture |
Laser re-austenitization alters local texture: expected change ≤ 5–10% (estimate) |
[51] |
Nitrides and carbides in steel |
γ′-Fe4N 159 ± 17 GPa [nv]; cementite 177–200 GPa (experimental values compiled in [53]) |
Nitrided and carburized layers are not stiffer than ferrite |
[52, 53] |
Laser-nitrided Ti-6Al-4V |
177 vs 114 GPa (layer vs substrate, as reported) |
Surface layer only; cracking |
[41, 42] |
Metastable β Ti-15-3 |
Solution treated 82 GPa; aged 107–111 GPa (+30–35%) |
α precipitation; through-thickness possible in 0.4–2.4 mm strip |
[34, 35] |
Ti-29Nb-13Ta-4.6Zr |
60–100 GPa depending on oxygen and ageing; UTS 600–1400 MPa |
α precipitation raises E |
[54] |
Ti-V, Ti-Nb, Ti-V-Sn |
Athermal or stress-induced ω raises E; minima 51–57 GPa when ω is suppressed |
– |
[55] |
ω-Ti (single phase, HPT) |
E and G of ω above both α and β |
ω is the stiffest Ti phase |
[56] |
Aged β-Ti, laser surface treatment |
Laser-melted β layer: lower E and hardness whatever the ageing; without melting, ω on cooling can cancel the drop |
Only direct demonstration found of a laser-induced stiffness gradient in a structural alloy |
[37, 38] |
NiTi |
B2 austenite ≈67–70 GPa; B19′ martensite in tension ≈25 GPa (literature 28–41); diffraction moduli of martensite ≈120 GPa |
Low martensite value is a tension-only effect of texture and anisotropy; switchable locally by laser [43] |
[57, 43] |
Fe78Si9B13 metallic glass ribbon, laser-crystallized stripes |
Modulus +20–30% (cited), density +3.1% |
24 µm ribbons; crystallization eigenstrain programs 3D buckling |
[58] |
Laser-hardened low-C plates |
Reported “stiffness” gains (+5% flexural, +8–21% axial in analytical estimates) |
Plastic origin (higher yield of the layer), not a modulus change |
[10] |
Synthesis. In steels, Young’s modulus is nearly phase-independent: martensite is 3% below ferrite–pearlite, austenite within a few % of ferrite, nitrides (Fe4N) are softer, cementite comparable. Texture can move in-plane E by up to ≈5–10% (estimate from [51]), and the stiff compounds of laser alloying stay in thin surface layers. A modulus architecture in steel is therefore not realistic; reported stiffness gains in laser-hardened steel plates are post-yield effects. Two systems offer a real, through-thickness modulus contrast. Metastable β-Ti: aged 107–111 GPa vs solution treated 82 GPa (+30–35%), with ω able to raise E further, and a published laser-induced stiffness gradient [37, 38]. The macroscopic effect is nevertheless small: for a 50/50 laminate of 82 and 110 GPa, the Voigt and Reuss bounds are 96 and 94 GPa, a ≈2% anisotropy (estimate), so the architecture acts on local load paths rather than on effective elasticity. NiTi: 67–70 GPa (B2) vs ≈25–40 GPa (B19′, tension) at room temperature, switchable locally [43]; the same bounds give 47.5 vs 36.8 GPa, ≈30% anisotropy (estimate), with a nonlinear, temperature-dependent response. In steels, an elastic architecture has to be geometric (thickness modulation, corrugation, laser forming) or based on eigenstrains: the transformation strain of laser tracks creates residual stresses and distortion that can program buckled or multistable shapes, as shown with crystallized stripes in metallic glass ribbons [58]; no such demonstration in steel sheets was found.
3. Steering and blunting cracks with local property gradients (Q3)¶
Table 3. Evidence and tools for crack control in heterogeneous metals.
Topic |
Key result |
Notes |
Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|
Strength mismatch in HAZ-notched welds |
Overmatch with moderately tough HAZ: crack deviates toward the softer material; embrittled HAZ: overmatch lowers critical CTOD through constraint |
Deep-notch geometry dominates constraint |
[59] |
Laser-welded Al6056 (undermatched fusion zone) |
Crack started in the HAZ kinks into the softer fusion zone; GTN reproduces the path, a cohesive model needs a prescribed path |
GTN to set limits for cheaper 2D cohesive runs |
[60] |
Micromechanical models for welds |
GTN and related models predict higher initiation and growth resistance of HAZ, constraint effects |
Review, steels and Al |
[61] |
Configurational forces |
Material inhomogeneity term C_inh adds to J_far: shielding or anti-shielding |
Elastic and elastic–plastic |
[62, 63] |
Periodic stiffness variation |
Design rules for flaw-tolerant multilayers (bone, nacre, sponges) |
Requires strong elastic contrast |
[64] |
Soft interlayers (yield stress inhomogeneity) |
Driving force drops strongly once the crack has crossed a soft interlayer: arrest without delamination; design variables: interlayer yield strength, thickness, spacing |
Elastic–ideally plastic analyses; steel laminates (X210CrW12 or C45 matrix, DC04 interlayers) arrest the crack in the first interlayer |
[65–67] |
Soft-to-hard transitions |
Fatigue crack coming from the softer steel slows and stops before the interface; from the harder side it passes |
Explosion-clad ferritic/austenitic steel |
[68] |
Fracture work contrast by laser tempering (22MnB5) |
w_e 38 (martensite), 130 (laser-tempered), 212 kJ/m² (F–P) |
Toughness ratio 3.4–5.6 within one sheet |
[4] |
Laser-hardened tracks, fatigue |
Fatigue life ×2–4; temporary arrest at track/matrix borders |
0.2 C and 0.45 C steels |
[69] |
Laser heating lines, residual stress |
Strong retardation in AA2198-T8; +285% crack growth life in 2 mm AA2024-T3 |
Compressive field between lines |
[70, 32] |
Functionally graded materials |
Phase-field FGM model identifies gradient profiles that prevent unstable fracture; ductile FGM study links plastic strain to crack paths and arrest |
Brittle [71]; ductile [72] |
[71, 72] |
Nacre-like and lamellar metals |
Mg–Ti composites: brick-and-mortar is the least tough (K at Δa = 1 mm: 31.8 vs 43.5 MPa√m for crossed-lamellar), cracks penetrate the bricks; heterogeneous lamella Ti: 3× CG strength at equal ductility |
Weak interfaces or strong contrast needed for deflection |
[73, 74] |
Damage and fracture models |
Rice–Tracey void growth; GTN; Johnson–Cook cumulative damage; review of continuum models; phase-field ductile fracture; element erosion vs phase-field convergence |
– |
[75–81] |
Synthesis. Three robust rules emerge. (i) Under strength mismatch, ductile cracks drift toward the softer material [59, 60], and a soft zone placed across the path shields the crack once crossed [65–67], whereas a crack running from hard to soft material is anti-shielded [62, 63, 68]; laser tempering or reversion lines in a hard matrix provide exactly the interlayer variables of Sistaninia and Kolednik (yield strength, width, spacing), in sheet form, with toughness ratios of 3.4–5.6 measured in 22MnB5 [4]. (ii) Hard zones bring low local toughness and constraint: hard tracks crossing a crack path in a soft matrix delay fatigue cracks at their borders [69] but can trigger cleavage if embrittled [59]. (iii) Brick-and-mortar layouts need weak interfaces: without them cracks cut through the bricks [73]; for laser architectures with moderate contrast and no interfaces, continuous soft lines across the expected path (laminate or crossed-lamellar type) are more promising than bricks. Residual-stress patterns from laser heating lines are a second, documented lever for fatigue [32, 70]; no study of monotonic ductile tearing in laser-architectured sheets was found, which leaves the field open. Modelling: an efficient chain is (a) stationary-crack screening of layouts with J and C_inh computed from graded property maps [62, 63]; (b) growth simulations with a regularized model, either nonlocal GTN, which captures path deviation in welds [60, 61], or phase-field ductile fracture [79, 80], which handles graded properties without remeshing [71, 72]; uncoupled Rice–Tracey or Johnson–Cook criteria with element erosion [75, 77] are cheap but give mesh-biased paths [81]; (c) calibration per phase on notched and shear specimens (triaxiality and Lode dependence [78]), 3D solids with several elements through the thickness to capture slant fracture (estimate), and validation by DIC and crack-path tracking.
4. State of the art: architectured sheets by laser or local heat treatment (Q4)¶
Table 4. Main lines of work.
Line of work |
Content |
Ref. |
|---|---|---|
Concept of architectured and heterogeneous materials |
Architecture as an extra length scale and spatial heterogeneity as a design variable; steel-based composites; expansion of materials space |
[82–84] |
Corrugated reinforcements (Fraser, Zurob, Wu, Bouaziz) |
FE on Cu–steel: corrugation raises necking strain, more with height; benefit only within a window of matrix strength, hardening and minimum reinforcement yield stress |
[85, 86] |
PIMM laser architecturing |
SCOLASTIC (2016–2020, PIMM with ArcelorMittal): optimized patterns applied at ≈1 mm resolution, laser tempering of DP sheet [87]; MS and DP laser treatment near Ac3 [12]; AISI 430 [2]; corrugated martensite in ferritic steel: at 24% reinforced fraction, higher corrugation raises necking strain and lowers YS and UTS (geometric hardening by unbending) [3]; thesis [1] |
[1–3, 12, 87] |
Tailor heat treated blanks (Merklein, Geiger) |
Local short-time heat treatment of Al blanks, drawing depth up to +86%; review of tailored blanks; 7075 laser treatment and distortion; 6063 laser softening |
[26–29] |
Laser-patterned crash structures (Kim, Yoon) |
Patterned martensite in as-received 22MnB5 sheet [6] and tubes: helical pattern +22.3% (+32.2% at optimal 12.5 mm pitch) static energy absorption [8], +13.1% dynamic [7] |
[6–8] |
Local laser treatment of the microstructure of sheets |
Austenite lines in Fe–Ni–C martensite [21, 22]; martensite/austenite stripes in 304 [18]; non-magnetic marks in cold-worked 304L [19]; magnetic/non-magnetic laminates by masked nitriding [20]; crystallized stripes programming 3D shapes in metallic glass ribbons [58]; local memories in NiTi [43–46] |
see column |
Related architectures in additive manufacturing |
Soft/hard layering by in-situ precipitation (Fe19Ni5Ti, 1300 MPa, 10%) [25]; programmed recrystallization in 316L: YS 322 vs 440 MPa, UE 46% vs 32%, architecture UTS 708 MPa [88] |
[25, 88] |
Synthesis. The field has moved from formability-driven tailoring (tailor heat treated Al blanks, soft zones in press-hardened parts) to architecture-driven patterning (PIMM, Kim and Yoon, TU Delft, recent 304 stripes). The exploited contrast is still almost always strength in steels, and the targets are necking strain, formability and crash energy. Elastic and fracture-oriented design remain open, as do non-ferrous alloys beyond Al.
5. Recommendation for a demonstrator¶
Cold-rolled metastable austenitic stainless steel (301/301LN full hard, 0.5–1.5 mm) with laser reversion tracks. Expected contrast: YS ≥ 965 MPa (full hard) vs 300–1000 MPa (reverted, tunable by peak temperature), elongation ≈9% vs ≈40%, plus a ferromagnetic/paramagnetic contrast that makes the architecture visible by magnetic imaging during loading (TRIP). Why: reversion completes in 1–100 s at 700–1000 °C with no quench and no hardenability limit; laser reversion and patterning are demonstrated [14–19]. Check grain growth at high peak temperature and the evolution of the contrast by TRIP.
Three-level C–Mn–B architecture (22MnB5 or MS1500-type, 1–2 mm): ferrite–pearlite, laser-tempered martensite, martensite, for the crack-steering demonstrator. Expected: UTS 594/920/1523 MPa and w_e 212/130/38 kJ/m² [4], arranged as soft lines across the crack path following the interlayer rules [65–67]. Why: process windows already mastered at PIMM [1–3, 12], largest combined strength and toughness contrast.
Aged metastable β-Ti strip (Ti-15-3, 0.4–2.4 mm) with laser re-solution tracks. Expected: YS 965–1172 → ≈770 MPa, elongation 5–7% → 22%, E 107–111 → 82 GPa [34, 35]. Why: the only structural alloy found with a through-thickness modulus contrast (±30%) and a published laser stiffness gradient [37, 38]; low conductivity keeps 1 mm features. To verify first: α dissolution at laser time scales, oxygen pick-up (shielding on both faces), ω in the heat-affected zone.
NiTi strip (0.3–0.5 mm), local laser annealing of cold-rolled strip or Ni-depletion pulses, for an elastic/functional demonstrator: apparent modulus ≈25–40 vs 67–70 GPa at room temperature, local Ms raised up to ≈65 °C so that treated zones are martensitic and the base austenitic [43, 57], with superelastic, shape memory and elastic domains in one sheet [44–46]. Limits: cost, sheet size, melting needed for Ni depletion.
Not recommended for architecture: AA2024 (low contrast, cracking; residual-stress patterning only), Al 6xxx/7xxx (≤ ≈35% and re-ageing), Mg (surface effects only), Cu–Be until laser data exist.
Elastic architecture. In steels, a modulus architecture is not realistic (contrast ≤ 3–5% by phase, ≤ 5–10% by texture); an elastic architecture in steel must be geometric or eigenstrain-based. A material stiffness architecture is realistic in β-Ti (local ±30%, but ≈2% macroscopic anisotropy for a 50/50 laminate, estimate) and in NiTi (≈2.7× apparent contrast, ≈30% anisotropy, nonlinear and temperature dependent, estimate). For a first elastic demonstrator, NiTi is the most convincing, β-Ti the most structural.
References¶
Wang Z. (2022). Architecturation de tôles métalliques par traitement laser localisé. PhD thesis, HESAM Université (Arts et Métiers, PIMM), defended 15/12/2022, NNT 2022HESAE065; HAL tel-04041478 (HAL id as provided, record checked on theses.fr). https://theses.fr/2022HESAE065
Wang Z., Dirrenberger J., Lapouge P., Dubent S. (2022). Laser treatment of 430 ferritic stainless steel for enhanced mechanical properties. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 831, 142205. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2021.142205
Wang Z., Bouaziz O., Dirrenberger J., Lapouge P. (2023). Corrugation reinforced architectured materials by direct laser hardening. Steel Res. Int. 94(6), 2200695. https://doi.org/10.1002/srin.202200695
Garcia-Llamas E., Pujante J., Frómeta D., et al. (2023). Optimization of thick 22MnB5 sheet steel part performance through laser tempering. Metals 13(2), 396. https://doi.org/10.3390/met13020396
Golovko O., Stolte M.-H., Wölki K., et al. (2020). Tailoring soft local zones in quenched blanks of the steel 22MnB5 by partial pre-cooling with compressed air. J. Mater. Eng. Perform. 29. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11665-020-04916-5
Kim H.-g., Lee H.-J., Park S.H., Park S.-J., Yoon J. (2020). Effect of laser patterning on the material behaviour of 22MnB5 steel with induced local strengthening. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 107, 4983–4994. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-020-05365-z
Kim H.G., Trinh N.H., Kwon J.B., et al. (2022). Crash performance of strength gradient tube induced by selective laser patterning. Materials 15(19), 6580. https://doi.org/10.3390/ma15196580
Kim H.-G., Yoon J. (2021). Effect of laser patterning on axial crushing performance of cylindrical 22MnB5 tubes. Compos. Struct. 262, 113633. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compstruct.2021.113633
Vogt S., Völl A., Wollgarten S., et al. (2019). Local laser softening of high-strength steel with an adapted intensity. J. Laser Appl. (volume [nv]). https://doi.org/10.2351/1.5052147
Kapustynskyi O., Višniakov N., Zabulionis D., Piščalov A. (2020). Feasibility evaluation of local laser treatment for strengthening of thin-walled structures from low-carbon steel subjected to bending. Materials 13(14), 3085. https://doi.org/10.3390/ma13143085
Xia M., Biro E., Tian Z., Zhou Y.N. (2008). Effects of heat input and martensite on HAZ softening in laser welding of dual phase steels. ISIJ Int. 48(6), 809–814. https://uwaterloo.ca/centre-advanced-materials-joining/sites/default/files/uploads/files/isij-2008_xia_2.pdf
Lapouge P., Dirrenberger J., Coste F., Schneider M. (2019). Laser heat treatment of martensitic steel and dual-phase steel with high martensite content. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 752, 128–135. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msea.2019.03.016
Atlas Steels (2008). Grade 301 datasheet (rev. May 2008). https://www.atlassteels.com.au/documents/Atlas%20Grade%20datasheet%20301%20rev%20May%202008.pdf
Somani M.C., Juntunen P., Karjalainen L.P., Misra R.D.K., Kyröläinen A. (2009). Enhanced mechanical properties through reversion in metastable austenitic stainless steels. Metall. Mater. Trans. A 40, 729–744. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11661-008-9723-y
Järvenpää A., Jaskari M., Kisko A., Karjalainen P. (2020). Processing and properties of reversion-treated austenitic stainless steels. Metals 10(2), 281. https://doi.org/10.3390/met10020281
Järvenpää A., Jaskari M., Karjalainen L.P., Hietala M. (2013). Enhancing mechanical properties and formability of AISI 301LN stainless steel sheet by local laser heat treatment. Key Eng. Mater. 554–557, 885 (author list from EPA HERO record [nv]). https://www.scientific.net/KEM.554-557.885
Hamada A.S., Järvenpää A., Ahmed E., Sahu P., Farahat A.I.Z. (2016). Enhancement in grain-structure and mechanical properties of laser reversion treated metastable austenitic stainless steel. Mater. Des. 94 (pages [nv]). https://eld.bl.uk/catalog/100037921264_0x000001
Ding R., et al. (2024). Strong yet ductile steels via a heterogeneous phase transformation strategy. Scripta Mater. 252, 116274 (full author list [nv]). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2024.116274
Leskovšek V., Godec M., Kogej P. (2016). Influence of low-temperature nitriding on the strain-induced martensite and laser-quenched austenite in a magnetic encoder made from 304L stainless steel. Sci. Rep. 6, 30979. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep30979
GE Research (ORNL record lists V.P. Rallabandi; author list [nv]) (2023). Development of dual phase soft magnetic laminate for advanced electric machines. AIP Adv. 13(2), 025021. https://doi.org/10.1063/9.0000380 (”≈2× tensile strength” from a summary of the DOE final report OSTI 1638508, not accessed [nv])
Breukelman H.J., Santofimia M.J., Hidalgo J. (2022). Hierarchically patterned multiphase steels created by localised laser treatments. Mater. Des. 221, 110984. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2022.110984
Breukelman H.J., Santofimia M.J., Hidalgo J. (2023). Engineering austenite/martensite mesostructured materials by controlled localised laser treatments in a Fe–Ni–C alloy. Mater. Des. 227, 111772 (author list [nv]). https://repository.tudelft.nl/record/uuid:ee8df385-816b-4029-b577-0a8987e1c3d1
Aircraft Materials. Maraging steel 300/C300 (UNS K93120), typical properties. https://aircraftmaterials.com/data/nickel/C300.html
Jägle E.A., Sheng Z., Kürnsteiner P., Ocylok S., Weisheit A., Raabe D. (2017). Comparison of maraging steel micro- and nanostructure produced conventionally and by laser additive manufacturing. Materials 10(1), 8. https://doi.org/10.3390/ma10010008
Kürnsteiner P., Wilms M.B., Weisheit A., Gault B., Jägle E.A., Raabe D. (2020). High-strength Damascus steel by additive manufacturing. Nature 582, 515–519. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-020-2409-3
Geiger M., Merklein M., Vogt U. (2009). Aluminum tailored heat treated blanks. Prod. Eng. 3(4–5), 401–410. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11740-009-0179-8
Merklein M., Johannes M., Lechner M., Kuppert A. (2014). A review on tailored blanks: production, applications and evaluation. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 214(2), 151–164. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2013.08.015
Peixinho N., Pereira R., Carneiro V., Cortez S., Costa S., Blanco V. (2024). Development of laser heat treatment process for assisted forming of aluminum alloys. Int. J. Eng. Model. 37(1), 1–14. https://doi.org/10.31534/engmod.2024.1.ri.01d
Rigas N., Merklein M. (2021). Numerical and experimental investigations for distortion-reduced laser heat treatment of aluminum. Prod. Eng. 15, 479–488. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11740-021-01029-3
Wiesenmayer S., Merklein M. (2022). Shear-clinching of the high-strength aluminum alloy AA7075 with laser-assisted retrogression. Proc. IMechE B. https://doi.org/10.1177/09544054221135103
Zieroth H., Stephan M., Schmidt M., Merklein M. (2025). Improving the local formability of a AA7075 aluminum alloy by laser-induced modification of the alloying concept. MATEC Web Conf. 408, 01018. https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/202540801018
Kashaev N., Groth A., Ventzke V., Horstmann M., Riekehr S., Staron P., Huber N. (2021). Effect of laser heating on mechanical properties, residual stresses and retardation of fatigue crack growth in AA2024. Fatigue Fract. Eng. Mater. Struct. 44(4), 887–900. https://doi.org/10.1111/ffe.13400
TWI (2023). Solidification cracking susceptibility of AA6061 and AA2024 aluminium alloys during laser welding. Core Research Programme report 1177/2023 (title only accessed [nv]). https://twi-global.com/what-we-do/research-and-technology/research-programmes/core-research-programme/report-abstracts/solidification-cracking-susceptibility-of-aa6061-and-aa2024-aluminium-alloys-during-laser-welding-1177-2023
TIMET (2000). TIMETAL 15-3 datasheet. https://www.timet.com/documents/datasheets/metastable-beta-alloys/timetal-15-3-3-3.pdf
Aerospace Metals. Titanium Ti-15V-3Cr-3Al-3Sn, solution treated, data sheet. https://www.aerospacemetals.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Titanium-Ti-15V-3Cr-3Al-3Sn-Solution-Treated-Data-Sheet.pdf
Michiyama Y., Demizu K. (2011). Surface age hardening and wear properties of beta-type titanium alloy by laser surface solution treatment. Mater. Trans. 52(4), 714–718. https://cir.nii.ac.jp/crid/1390282679228154368
da Costa et al. (2020). Stiffness and hardness gradients obtained by laser surface melting of an aged β-Ti alloy. Mater. Lett. 260, 126901 (author list [nv]). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matlet.2019.126901
da Costa et al. (2023). Stiffness and hardness gradients obtained by laser surface treatment of aged β-Ti alloys: the role of ω phase. Surf. Coat. Technol. 467 (author list and article number [nv]). https://riunet.upv.es/handle/10251/212066
He B., Cheng X., Li J., Li G.C., Wang H.M. (2017). ω-assisted α phase and hardness of Ti-5Al-5Mo-5V-1Cr-1Fe during low temperature isothermal heat treatment after laser surface remelting. J. Alloys Compd. 708, 1054–1062. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2017.03.089
Hahn, Shin, Krane (2007). Laser transformation hardening of Ti-6Al-4V in solid state with accompanying kinetic model. Surf. Eng. (initials, volume and DOI [nv]). https://bvbvf1.bib-bvb.de/vufind/PrimoRecord/cdi_proquest_miscellaneous_29347037
Biswas A., Li L., Chatterjee U.K., Manna I., Pabi S.K., Dutta Majumdar J. (2008). Mechanical and electrochemical properties of laser surface nitrided Ti-6Al-4V. Scripta Mater. 59, 239–242 (modulus label as reported [nv]). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2008.03.020
Shirazi H.A., Chan C.-W., Lee S. (2021). Elastic-plastic properties of titanium and its alloys modified by fibre laser surface nitriding for orthopaedic implant applications. J. Mech. Behav. Biomed. Mater. 124, 104802. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmbbm.2021.104802
Khan M.I., Pequegnat A., Zhou Y.N. (2013). Multiple memory shape memory alloys. Adv. Eng. Mater. 15(5), 386–393. https://doi.org/10.1002/adem.201200246
Bellouard Y., Lehnert T., Bidaux J.E., Sidler T., Clavel R., Gotthardt R. (1999). Local annealing of complex mechanical devices: a new approach for developing monolithic micro-devices. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 273–275, 795–798. https://infoscience.epfl.ch/record/210170
Meng Q., Liu Y., Yang H., Shariat B.S., Nam T.-H. (2012). Functionally graded NiTi strips prepared by laser surface anneal. Acta Mater. 60(4), 1658–1668. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2011.11.052
Yang Y., Wu Z.G., Shen B.Y., et al. (2021). Graded functionality obtained in NiTi shape memory alloy via a repetitive laser processing strategy. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 296, 117177. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2021.117177
Fiskalloy. C17200 beryllium copper, tensile strength by temper. https://fiskalloy.com/product/c17200/
Ge Y.Q., Wang W.X., Guo S., Cui Z.Q., Xu B.S. (2015). Laser surface melting of AZ31B magnesium alloy under extreme cooling conditions. Lasers Eng. 30(5–6), 389–401. https://www.oldcitypublishing.com/journals/lie-home/lie-issue-contents/lie-volume-30-number-5-6-2015/lie-30-5-6-p-389-401/
Kim S.A., Johnson W.L. (2007). Elastic constants and internal friction of martensitic steel, ferritic-pearlitic steel, and α-iron. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 452–453, 633–639. https://www.nist.gov/publications/elastic-constants-and-internal-friction-martensitic-steel-ferritic-pearlitic-steel-and
SSINA. Composition/Properties (elastic moduli of stainless grades). https://www.ssina.com/?p=1291
JFE Steel. US Patent 10,472,697, High-strength steel sheet and production method therefor. https://patents.justia.com/patent/10472697
Takahashi T., Burghaus J., Music D., Dronskowski R., Schneider J.M. (2012). Elastic properties of γ′-Fe4N probed by nanoindentation and ab initio calculation. Acta Mater. 60(5), 2054 (read through the citing preprint arXiv:2411.17193 [nv]). https://arxiv.org/abs/2411.17193
Liyanage L.S.I., Houze J., Kim S., et al. (2014). Structural, elastic and thermal properties of cementite (Fe3C) calculated using modified embedded atom method. Phys. Rev. B 89, 094102. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.89.094102
Nakai M., Niinomi M., Akahori T., Tsutsumi H., Ogawa M. (2009). Effect of oxygen content on microstructure and mechanical properties of biomedical Ti-29Nb-13Ta-4.6Zr alloy under solutionized and aged conditions. Mater. Trans. 50(12), 2716–2720. https://doi.org/10.2320/matertrans.MA200904
Matsumoto H., Watanabe S., Masahashi N., Hanada S. (2006). Composition dependence of Young’s modulus in Ti-V, Ti-Nb, and Ti-V-Sn alloys. Metall. Mater. Trans. A 37, 3239–3249. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02586159
Tane M., et al. (2013). Elastic properties of single-crystalline ω phase in titanium. Acta Mater. 61(20), 7543–7554. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2013.08.036
Šittner P., Heller L., Pilch J., Curfs C., Alonso T., Favier D. (2014). Young’s modulus of austenite and martensite phases in superelastic NiTi wires. J. Mater. Eng. Perform. 23(7), 2303–2314. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11665-014-0976-x
Li J.-F., Soldatov I.V., Tang X.-C., et al. (2022). Metallic Mimosa pudica: a 3D biomimetic buckling structure made of metallic glasses. Sci. Adv. 8(31), eabm7658. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abm7658
Minami F., Toyoda M., Thaulow C., Hauge M. (1995). Effect of strength mis-match on fracture mechanical behavior of HAZ-notched weld joint. Q. J. Jpn. Weld. Soc. 13(4), 508–517. https://doi.org/10.2207/qjjws.13.508
Nègre P., Steglich D., Brocks W. (2005). Crack extension at an interface: prediction of fracture toughness and simulation of crack path deviation. Int. J. Fract. 134(3–4), 209–229. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10704-005-0523-8
Rakin M., Medjo B., Gubeljak N., Sedmak A. (2020). An overview of application of micromechanical models in ductile fracture analysis of welded joints. Theor. Appl. Mech. 47(1), 33–62. https://doi.org/10.2298/TAM200117004R
Simha N.K., Fischer F.D., Kolednik O., Chen C.R. (2003). Inhomogeneity effects on the crack driving force in elastic and elastic–plastic materials. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 51, 209–240 (as cited in a 2006 conference paper by Kolednik et al. [nv]). https://www.gruppofrattura.it/ocs/index.php/esis/CP2006/paper/download/9458/6102
Simha N.K., et al. (2008). J-integral and crack driving force in elastic–plastic materials. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 56, 2876–2895 (author list [nv]). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmps.2008.04.003
Kolednik O., Predan J., Fischer F.D., Fratzl P. (2011). Bioinspired design criteria for damage-resistant materials with periodically varying microstructure. Adv. Funct. Mater. 21(19), 3634–3641. https://doi.org/10.1002/adfm.201100443
Sistaninia M., Kolednik O. (2014). Effect of a single soft interlayer on the crack driving force. Eng. Fract. Mech. 130, 21–41. https://manuscript.isc.ac/Inventory/10/2344374.htm
Sistaninia M., Kolednik O. (2017). Improving strength and toughness of materials by utilizing spatial variations of the yield stress. Acta Mater. 122, 207–219. https://eld.bl.uk/catalog/100180754168_0x000001
Sistaninia M., Kasberger R., Kolednik O. (2018). To the design of highly fracture-resistant composites by the application of the yield stress inhomogeneity effect. Compos. Struct. 185, 113–122. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compstruct.2017.10.081
Suresh S., Sugimura Y., Tschegg E.K. (1992). The growth of a fatigue crack approaching a perpendicularly-oriented, bimaterial interface. Scripta Metall. Mater. 27, 1189–1194 (as cited in later work [nv]). https://link.springer.com/article/10.1023/A:1007605224764
Kocanda S., Natkaniec D., Sniezek L. (1994). Fatigue behaviour of laser hardened steel: comparison study for low, medium carbon steels, high strength and carburized CrMn steels. WIT Trans. Eng. Sci. 6. https://doi.org/10.2495/LD940041
Schnubel D., Horstmann M., Ventzke V., Riekehr S., Staron P., Fischer T., Huber N. (2012). Retardation of fatigue crack growth in aircraft aluminium alloys via laser heating: experimental proof of concept. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 546, 8–14 (volume from a citing paper [nv]). https://publications.hereon.de/id/29584
Hirshikesh, Natarajan S., Annabattula R.K., Martínez-Pañeda E. (2019). Phase field modelling of crack propagation in functionally graded materials. Compos. B 169, 239–248. https://arxiv.org/abs/1904.08749
Piper K., Agrawal V. (2024). Ductile fracture in functionally graded materials: insight into crack behavior within the gradient interface. arXiv:2411.18642. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2411.18642
Zhang M., Zhao N., Yu Q., et al. (2022). On the damage tolerance of 3-D printed Mg-Ti interpenetrating-phase composites with bioinspired architectures. Nat. Commun. 13, 3247. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-30873-9
Wu X., Yang M., Yuan F., Wu G., Wei Y., Huang X., Zhu Y. (2015). Heterogeneous lamella structure unites ultrafine-grain strength with coarse-grain ductility. PNAS 112(47), 14501–14505. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1517193112
Rice J.R., Tracey D.M. (1969). On the ductile enlargement of voids in triaxial stress fields. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 17(3), 201–217. https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-5096(69)90033-7
Tvergaard V., Needleman A. (1984). Analysis of the cup-cone fracture in a round tensile bar. Acta Metall. 32(1), 157–169. https://doi.org/10.1016/0001-6160(84)90213-X
Johnson G.R., Cook W.H. (1985). Fracture characteristics of three metals subjected to various strains, strain rates, temperatures and pressures. Eng. Fract. Mech. 21(1), 31–48. https://doi.org/10.1016/0013-7944(85)90052-9
Besson J. (2010). Continuum models of ductile fracture: a review. Int. J. Damage Mech. 19(1), 3–52. https://doi.org/10.1177/1056789509103482
Ambati M., Gerasimov T., De Lorenzis L. (2015). Phase-field modeling of ductile fracture. Comput. Mech. 55, 1017–1040. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00466-015-1151-4
Miehe C., Aldakheel F., Raina A. (2016). Phase field modeling of ductile fracture at finite strains: a variational gradient-extended plasticity-damage theory. Int. J. Plast. 84 (pages [nv]; reference read in an ECCOMAS 2022 abstract). https://congress.cimne.com/eccomas2022/admin/files/fileabstract/a1101.pdf
Pandolfi A., Weinberg K., Ortiz M. (2021). A comparative accuracy and convergence study of eigenerosion and phase-field models of fracture. arXiv:2101.12520. https://arxiv.org/abs/2101.12520
Bouaziz O., Bréchet Y., Embury J.D. (2008). Heterogeneous and architectured materials: a possible strategy for design of structural materials. Adv. Eng. Mater. 10(1–2), 24–36. https://doi.org/10.1002/adem.200700289
Embury D., Bouaziz O. (2010). Steel-based composites: driving forces and classifications. Annu. Rev. Mater. Res. 40, 213–241. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-matsci-070909-104438
Bréchet Y., Embury J.D. (2013). Architectured materials: expanding materials space. Scripta Mater. 68(1), 1–3. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2012.07.038
Fraser M., Zurob H., Wu P. (2018). Corrugation reinforced composites: a method for filling holes in material-property space. Adv. Eng. Mater. 20(1), 1700834. https://doi.org/10.1002/adem.201700834
Fraser M., Zurob H., Wu P., Bouaziz O. (2020). Increasing necking strain through corrugation: identifying composite systems that can benefit from corrugated geometry. Materials 13(22), 5175. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7696636/
ANR (2016). SCOLASTIC: Systematic Computational Optimisation and Local Laser Processing for Steel-Based Architectured Materials, ANR-16-CE08-0009 (PIMM, ArcelorMittal). https://anr.fr/Project-ANR-16-CE08-0009
Gao S., Li Z., Van Petegem S., et al. (2023). Additive manufacturing of alloys with programmable microstructure and properties. Nat. Commun. 14, 6752. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-42326-y