Architectured sheets by localized laser treatment

morphogen.laser simulates and optimizes metal sheets architectured by a laser: a beam (or two aligned beams, one on each face) follows a path that hardens — or softens, carburizes, nitrides, alloys — narrow tracks of the sheet; the pattern of the tracks gives the sheet a behaviour that neither phase has alone (Bouaziz, Bréchet & Embury 2008; Brechet & Embury 2013). The module follows the PhD thesis of Zhige Wang (Architecturation de tôles métalliques par traitement laser localisé, HESAM Université, PIMM, 2022) and the ANR project SCOLASTIC (ANR-16-CE08-0009: “systematic computational optimisation and local laser processing for steel-based architectured materials”), whose loop it closes: a process model gives the hardness that a path leaves in the sheet, a finite element model gives the response of the specimen, an optimizer changes the path.

The formulas are in theory, the classes and functions in the API reference. This page reads in four parts:

  • the model: the choices of a study, the chain of models and what checks them (§1 to §3), and how to run it (§12, Use);

  • the results on tensile specimens and on other structures: the first results, the fracture of the martensite, a crack, a corner, the anisotropy and other materials (§4, §5, §10 and §11);

  • the design of the treated pattern: cell by cell, by densities, as laser paths, and with morphoGen’s morphologies at the scale of the spot (§6 to §8, §14);

  • the geometric work hardening of corrugated tracks, where it works, and the crossed families of straight tracks that lock (§15 to §17).

§9 places the module among related work and §13 states its limits; the literature survey gathers the materials that a laser treatment turns into two-phase sheets.

1. The choices of a study

The thesis left six choices open; the module takes each as an input, with defaults that the literature and the simulations below support.

Choice

Default

Alternatives in the module

Why

Load case and objective

uniaxial tension of a flat specimen along the rolling direction; maximize the strength–ductility product R_m A_g at a minimum yield strength

the energy absorbed up to necking, A_g, R_m, R_p, targets; tension in several directions (specimens cut at 0°, 45°, 90° from the treated sheet: the anisotropy of its yield, an isotropy objective); three-point bending of a strip (the load at a deflection, the limit load, the energy); constraints on any measure

hardening leaves Young’s modulus unchanged, so stiffness and elastic buckling cannot improve; the pattern acts on yielding, strain hardening and necking, which tension measures cheaply (Considère’s maximum of the force); the case of the thesis and of the literature (Fraser et al. 2018a, 2020; Wang et al. 2023; Breukelman et al. 2022). The product alone favours the untreated sheet: the yield constraint fixes the strength level at which ductility is sought

Base material

MS1500 annealed at 850 °C (ferrite–pearlite, 0.23 C, 1.7 Mn, 1 mm; 167 HV, R_p 300 MPa)

AISI 430 (0.5 mm), DP1180 (soft tracks), any material given as a mapping

the largest contrast of the hard tracks (laser martensite of about 500 HV, R_p about 1300 MPa: a ratio near 4) — corrugated reinforcements only pay off when the reinforcement stays nearly elastic while the matrix flows (Fraser et al. 2020); AISI 430 hardens by 50 % at most (ratio 1.56 in argon) and its corrugations gave nothing (thesis ch. 3); soft tracks in a hard sheet localize strain and fail early (Lapouge et al. 2019, Wang 2020 report)

Treatment

transformation hardening (martensite), peak between Ac3 and the solidus

carburizing from a graphite coating, nitriding under nitrogen, alloying from a pre-placed coating (melt pool); tempering of martensitic sheets

no coating, no melting needed in a C–Mn steel; carburizing raises the contrast of low-carbon steels (430: +130 % HV, thesis ch. 4) but needs melting (columnar grains, oxide: argon); nitrogen dissolves in iron only with chromium (0.04 wt% in Fe, 0.3 in Fe–18Cr at 1 atm)

Specimen

flat dog-bone, parallel part 30 × 5 × 1 mm, fillets of radius 6 mm, grips 10 mm wide; a DIC-like extensometer over 25 mm

strip (clamped or free ends), any dimensions

the specimens of Wang (2022, ch. 5): one track 1.2 mm wide is 24 % of the section

Laser configuration

symmetric: a Gaussian fibre beam (150 W, 1 mm) above and a top-hat diode (100 W, 1.2 mm) below, together, 10 mm/s

single (the upper face), the same beam on both faces

the platform of Wang et al. (2022): through 0.5 mm the gap of peak temperature is about 10 K with two beams and 260 K with one; the tracks are then through-thickness reinforcements, which unbend together

Pattern (laser path)

one corrugated track y = A sin(2π x/P) along the load, its amplitude and period optimized

straight, oblique, Fourier waveforms (free shapes), crossed families, honeycombs, any polylines

the geometric work hardening of corrugations that unbend (Bouaziz 2013; Fraser et al. 2014, 2018a): A/P trades yield strength for uniform elongation (Wang et al. 2023)

Process constraints enter as constraints of the optimization: the smallest gap between tracks (closer tracks temper each other; Wang waited at least 30 s between neighbouring tracks), the smallest radius of curvature of a track (the cycles of the model are those of a straight track: radii above the heated width; and the kinematics of the robot), the length of the path in the specimen (time and energy).

2. The chain of models

  1. Heat (laser.heat). A beam of absorbed power P moving at v on a plate of thickness h: the plane profile of the beam (Gaussian or top hat) spread by the heat kernel, images through the thickness for adiabatic faces, a second beam on the lower face, surface losses; the quasi-steady field T(ξ, y, z) is one integral over the delay, a product of matrices on grids. Its limits are Rosenthal’s point source and Rykalin’s line source with losses. A straight track then imposes a thermal cycle T(t; d, z) on each point at the distance d of its axis and the depth z (TrackKernel). Transient finite volumes of the whole blank (implicit, split along x, y and z) check the quasi-steady cycles and give the heat that the previous tracks leave.

  2. Metallurgy (laser.metallurgy). C–Mn steels: austenite at the peak of each cycle (lever rule with the A3 line, Ac1 and Ac3 of Andrews plus a superheat of the laser heating rates), martensite on cooling (Koistinen–Marburger below Andrews’s Ms of the austenite’s carbon; bainite beyond a critical cooling time t8/5), hardnesses of Maynier et al. (1978), tempering of martensite by the Hollomon–Jaffe parameter accumulated by additivity. AISI 430: the hardness gained as a function of the peak temperature (calibrated on the thesis), tempered the same way. Carburizing, nitriding and alloying: the coating (or nitrogen, Sieverts) mixed into the melt pool of each track by mass balance.

  3. Strength (laser.materials). The tensile properties of each state against its hardness (measured: the base and the fully treated 430 at 15 and 20 kJ/m, the carburized 430, the annealed MS1500 and its martensite), interpolated, extrapolated by Pavlina & Van Tyne’s correlations; each point gets the Ludwik (or Voce) law fitted to R_p, R_m and A_g by Considère’s condition.

  4. Treatment of a path (laser.process). The tracks in their order: the distance of each Gauss point to a track gives its cycle at each layer; untouched points take the tabulated response of the track, the others (the neighbours of earlier tracks) integrate their cycle — the tempered rings, the re-hardened crossings.

  5. Mechanics (laser.mechanics, laser.bending). The specimen as a membrane of bilinear quadrilaterals in plane stress, each Gauss point a stack of layers with their own flow laws; large rotations by a corotational update of the logarithmic strain increments (the unbending of the corrugations), von Mises plasticity by a radial return with the thickness strain from σ33 = 0, the consistent tangent of the Kirchhoff stress; displacement-controlled tension to past the maximum force. In several directions, the pattern is turned by the opposite angle and repeated at its spacing over the sheet before the specimen is cut. Three-point bending: the strip as a statically determinate beam whose sections are grids of fibres (across the width, through the layers) with their own flow laws, the neutral axis from the axial equilibrium (off the mid-plane under a one-sided treatment), the moment–curvature of each section inverted for the moment of the load, the deflection by virtual work.

  6. Optimization (laser.design). Parameters of the pattern and of the beams between bounds; grid, Nelder–Mead, differential evolution, genetic algorithm, or Bayesian optimization (a Gaussian process of the penalized costs, the expected improvement): a few tens of evaluations of a few seconds each.

3. Checks

The tests (tests/test_laser.py) compare with closed forms and independent computations: the moving source with Rosenthal’s thick-plate and Rykalin’s thin-plate solutions (2e-4); the energy P/v of a cross-section far behind the beam (2e-3); the transient finite volumes with the quasi-steady cycles (4 %); Andrews’s and Maynier’s values (the annealed MS1500: 173 HV computed, 167 ± 6 measured); the lever rule at A1 (the pearlite at once) and A3; Koistinen–Marburger after a quench; the additivity of the Hollomon–Jaffe parameter (an isothermal hold in 50 steps equals the formula to 1e-6); Sieverts’s solubility; the mass balance of a carburized melt; the flow laws against the tensile properties they are fitted to (1e-6); the arc length and curvature of corrugated tracks; the membrane in uniaxial tension against the exact response of a homogeneous strip (2e-4 on the curve, R_m to 1e-4, A_g to 2e-3); the tangent against finite differences (2e-5); a rigid rotation that turns the stresses and leaves the plastic strain; two bands along the load at equal strain (5e-3).

Against the experiments of the thesis (measured values in brackets):

  • AISI 430, 0.5 mm, double laser: at 50 + 50 W the mid-thickness stays below Ac1 [below Ac1]; at 100 + 100 W the track reaches the melting point through the thickness [peak near Tm]; at 150 + 100 W it melts [full fusion at 25 kJ/m].

  • Annealed MS1500, 1 mm, 150 + 100 W, absorptivity 0.55: austenitized through the thickness over 1.14 mm [tracks of 1.2 mm, nearly fully martensitic].

  • AISI 430 fully treated by ten tracks at 1 mm pitch, double laser under argon, after the hardness gained at 1300 °C and the tempering of the gain were fitted to the mean hardness of these sheets (212, 240 and 235 HV computed [211.5, 241.8, 233.6]):

    Energy

    R_p (MPa)

    R_m (MPa)

    A_g (%)

    15 kJ/m (75 + 75 W)

    468 [488.7]

    626 [623.5]

    15.6 [15.52]

    20 kJ/m (100 + 100 W)

    525 [539.7]

    704 [702.5]

    13.7 [13.65]

    25 kJ/m (150 + 100 W)

    507 [513.0]

    682 [680.6]

    14.1 [13.91]

    The tempering of earlier tracks by the next ones, which the thesis held responsible for the drop from 20 to 25 kJ/m, gives it here too.

4. First results

All simulated (elements of 0.5 mm, four layers; the uniform elongation moves by up to 15 % on elements of 0.25 mm, the trends do not).

Corrugated martensite in annealed MS1500 (one track, about 28 % of the section; Wang et al. 2023 found, at 24 %, that a larger height over period gains necking strain and loses yield and tensile strength; their tests in brackets, R_p/R_m/A):

Track

R_p (MPa)

R_m (MPa)

A_g (%)

energy (MJ/m³)

R_m A_g (MPa)

tests

none (annealed sheet)

293

535

16.4

81

88

300/534/16.7

straight

495

848

8.3

64

70

458/878/8.3

P = 15 mm, H = 0.5 mm

446

839

8.9

67

75

456/868/8.5

P = 15 mm, H = 1.0 mm

397

831

10.4

76

86

424/860/8.6

P = 15 mm, H = 1.5 mm

366

814

13.1

92

107

405/843/10.3

P = 30 mm, H = 1.5 mm

380

843

8.8

65

74

418/870/8.9

P = 10 mm, H = 1.5 mm

365

722

16.8

112

121

393/778/13.9

The height over the period sets the trade-off, as measured: at H/P = 0.15 the sheet keeps the uniform elongation of the annealed steel with a yield strength 25 % higher and absorbs more energy up to necking. The martensite of the tracks follows the Hollomon law Wang et al. identified (K 1966 MPa, n 0.06; its uniform elongation 0.062 by Considère — the 0.036 measured on the martensite alone is its fracture, which the matrix delays): the straight track necks at the measured 8.3 %. The corrugated tracks neck later than they failed in the tests (16.8 % against 13.9 % for P 10, H 1.5): the martensite breaks first (§5).

The other choices (one or two tracks):

Case

R_p

R_m

A_g (%)

energy

reading

AISI 430, no track

344

504

19.4

92

AISI 430, two straight tracks (23 %)

403

579

16.6

90

a low contrast: strength for ductility

AISI 430, two corrugated tracks (P 6, H 1)

392

578

16.2

88

no gain from corrugation (thesis ch. 3)

AISI 430 carburized, two straight tracks

453

700

10.6

70

carburizing raises the contrast

AISI 430 carburized, two corrugated tracks

399

666

15.7

97

now the corrugation pays (thesis ch. 4: “very limited”)

AISI 430 nitrided (N2), two straight tracks

426

609

13.8

78

between hardening and carburizing

annealed MS1500, single beam 250 W, straight

468

812

9.0

66

thinner, graded tracks (24 %)

annealed MS1500, single beam 250 W, corrugated P 15 H 1

398

814

9.8

70

less gain than with two beams (10.4 %, 76)

annealed MS1500, three hard bands across the load

319

543

10.4

52

in series: little strength, less ductility

annealed MS1500, crossed tracks at ±45°

364

594

5.3

28

shear bands between the tracks

DP1180, no track

821

1211

4.9

51

DP1180, three tempered bands across the load

788

1117

3.9

37

soft bands localize the strain

Bending (a strip 40 × 10 × 1 mm of annealed MS1500, span 30 mm; four tracks along it; the load at a deflection of 1 mm, the largest load of the tables, the energy to 1 mm):

Treatment

load at 1 mm (N)

largest load (N)

energy (mJ)

treated

none

119

167

83

0

both faces, 150 + 100 W

227

404

122

0.59

upper face, 250 W

226

380

122

0.51

upper face, 150 W

151

223

96

0.13

both faces, four tracks across the strip

152

167

101

0.46

The stiffness does not change (291.5 N/mm in every case: hardening keeps Young’s modulus). In bending a beam on one face only, if powerful enough to harden most of the thickness, does as well as the pair; tracks across the strip leave weak sections between them, so that the limit load stays that of the untreated strip. The template laser_bending optimizes the number of tracks and the power of a single beam for the load at 1 mm within a budget of laser energy.

Anisotropy. One corrugated track (P 15 mm, H 1 mm) in specimens cut at 0°, 45° and 90° from the treated sheet: R_m 831, 560 and 558 MPa, R_p 397, 327 and 330 MPa, the uniform elongation 10.4, 9.1 and 10.1 %: a strongly anisotropic sheet (R_p spread 20 % of its mean), the case for the isotropy objective of SCOLASTIC’s first application.

Optimization. The template laser_corrugated (morphogen template laser_corrugated) optimizes the amplitude and period of the track for R_m A_g with R_p ≥ 400 MPa and a radius of curvature of at least 1.5 mm, by Bayesian optimization. The constraint binds: the corrugation that gains ductility loses yield strength, and P 15 mm, H 1 mm (R_p 397 MPa, R_m A_g 86 MPa) lies on it; with twenty evaluations (34 s) the search ends at A ≈ 0.25 mm, P ≈ 6.1 mm (R_p 469 MPa, R_m 829 MPa, A_g 8.6 %, R_m A_g 71 MPa against 70 for the straight track): a few dozen more evaluations, or the amplitude bounded below, are needed along the boundary.

5. Reaching the thesis: the fracture of the martensite

The tests of Wang et al. (2023) fail when the martensite of the track cracks (their fractography: the crack starts in the reinforcement and crosses the matrix), and a corrugation delays it by straining the martensite less than the matrix (their DIC maps). Considère’s criterion alone, as in their finite elements, misses this: it predicts the necking of a straight track at 9.6 % against the 8.3 % measured. The module gives the brittle phase a critical plastic strain (Membrane(critical=...)), reached locally or — the crack crossing a whole track, not a point of its edge — averaged over a radius of about the width of a track (fracture_radius, mechanics.Fracture, the nonlocal average of Pijaudier-Cabot & Bažant 1987). With the phases of the paper (Hollomon laws of the annealed matrix and of the martensite, wang_phases), tracks of constant area (band_fractions, constant_area_width: the spot shrunk by defocusing), the critical strain 0.072 fitted to sample 1 alone and a radius of 1.5 mm:

Sample

H/P

here: R_p / R_m / failure

their FE: R_p / R_m / necking

tests

1, straight

0

469 / 764 / 0.083 (fitted)

434 / 757 / 0.096

458 / 878 / 0.083

2, P 15 H 0.5

0.033

418 / 751 / 0.083

385 / 755 / 0.099

456 / 868 / 0.085

3, P 15 H 1.0

0.067

370 / 741 / 0.088

349 / 748 / 0.101

424 / 860 / 0.086

4, P 15 H 1.5

0.1

340 / 738 / 0.108

316 / 741 / 0.113

405 / 843 / 0.103

5, P 30 H 1.5

0.05

358 / 751 / 0.090

327 / 757 / 0.097

418 / 870 / 0.089

6, P 10 H 1.5

0.15

334 / 694 / 0.127

308 / 686 / 0.132

393 / 778 / 0.139

The failure strains of the five corrugated samples follow the tests within 0.006 (root mean square; 0.011 for Considère in their FE); the radius matters (0.036 at the Gauss points, 0.013 over 1 mm), not the mesh (0.006 on elements of 0.25 mm, the critical strain then 0.075). The strengths are those of their FE: both ignore the partly transformed zone around the track, which the process model of §2 has (848 MPa for the straight track, measured 878).

Design maps (their Fig. 10, P = 10 mm, R_m in MPa / failure strain):

treated

H/P 0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.3

12 %

632 / 0.082

628 / 0.088

622 / 0.099

625 / 0.135

627 / 0.199

569 / 0.207

24 %

764 / 0.083

743 / 0.083

722 / 0.099

692 / 0.126

667 / 0.181

575 / 0.181

36 %

868 / 0.080

850 / 0.070

786 / 0.073

719 / 0.092

681 / 0.137

604 / 0.179

48 %

1001 / 0.080

948 / 0.055

838 / 0.051

764 / 0.073

707 / 0.109

637 / 0.208

The strengths of the straight tracks are those of their maps (652, 757, 877 and 1005 MPa); the failure strains are not: with a brittle martensite a straight track fails at about 8 % whatever its share (Considère gave them 18 % at 12 % and 6 % at 48 %), a slight corrugation lowers it in the wide tracks (strain on their edges), and the gain needs H/P above about 0.1 — the threshold of the paper, here for every fraction. Up to H/P = 0.2 the 12 % and 24 % sheets more than double their failure strain for a loss of strength of 1 % and 13 %.

The strength contrast (the third axis of the design space, examples/laser_contrast.py). The maps above hold the phases of the paper, a martensite whose yield stress is 4.64 times the matrix’s. contrast_phases gives the states between them: the Hollomon parameters interpolated from the matrix (σ0 280 MPa, K 986 MPa, n 0.24) to the martensite (1300, 1966, 0.06), a yield stress c times the matrix’s for c from 1 to 4.64, a harder state hardening less: a track partly transformed by an intercritical peak, or tempered by a second pass (the levels of a multi-level treatment). Their toughness is not measured. The rule graded divides the critical strain of the martensite by the square of the share of the interpolation (0.072 at c = 4.64, 0.11 at 4, 0.24 at 3: below about 2.8 the reinforcement never breaks first); brittle keeps 0.072 at every contrast and ductile removes the fracture (the necking alone), the two bounds. The specimen is the dog-bone of Wang et al., with a single track of constant area along it. A design is feasible when the radius of curvature of its track is at least 1.5 mm (H/P ≤ 0.169 at P = 10 mm) and when the track stays within the gauge (H + t/2 ≤ 2.5 mm: H/P ≤ 0.136 at P = 15 mm and 24 %). Beyond, the specimen holds pieces of oblique tracks and less of the treatment (13 % instead of 24 % at P = 15 mm, H/P = 0.25; the maps above from H/P = 0.25 on). The study runs 1450 designs (seven contrasts, four fractions, H/P from 0 to 0.3 at P = 10 mm and to 0.15 at 15 mm, three rules) on elements of 0.5 mm. At 24 % and P = 10 mm, the straight track and the corrugation at the process limit (H/P = 0.15), R_m (MPa) / failure strain (%) / energy (MJ/m³), and the gain of failure strain of the best feasible corrugation under each rule:

c

straight, graded

H/P 0.15, graded

gain, graded

brittle

ductile

1.5

578 / 25.3 / 134

575 / 25.4 / 133

+0 %

+19 %

+0 %

2

605 / 24.2 / 134

597 / 24.4 / 133

+1 %

+32 %

+1 %

2.5

633 / 23.0 / 134

619 / 23.6 / 133

+3 %

+44 %

+3 %

3

664 / 21.7 / 133

642 / 22.9 / 134

+6 %

+52 %

+6 %

3.5

695 / 17.2 / 110

665 / 21.2 / 127

+23 %

+54 %

+11 %

4

721 / 11.8 / 77

682 / 16.8 / 100

+43 %

+55 %

+17 %

4.64 (martensite)

763 / 8.1 / 56

693 / 12.6 / 75

+55 %

+55 %

+32 %

The matrix alone reaches 553 MPa, 26.3 % and 133 MJ/m³; the reinforcement alone (graded) 655 MPa and 22.7 % at c = 1.5, 1015 MPa and 13.7 % at 3, 1558 MPa and 6.7 % at 4.64. Five findings:

  1. Below a contrast of about 3 the corrugation does nothing, unless the reinforcement is brittle. A reinforcement that flows with the matrix (the graded rule below 3, where it does not reach its critical strain, and the ductile bound) gains 0 to 6 % of failure strain at the process limit and loses up to 3 % of strength: too soft to stay nearly elastic while the matrix flows, the condition of the geometric hardening (Fraser et al. 2020). The hardened AISI 430 of the thesis (c from 1.4 to 1.6, a ductile track) sits there: its corrugations gave nothing. In this family a softer state also hardens more; the carburized 430 of §4, whose track hardens little (A_g 10 %), gains from its corrugation.

  2. Above it, the gain grows with the contrast and with the brittleness of the reinforcement: graded, +23 % at c = 3.5, +43 % at 4, +55 % at the martensite (8.1 to 12.6 %, R_m −9 %). A brittle reinforcement gains from 19 % at c = 1.5 to 55 %: the corrugation strains it less than the matrix (the DIC of Wang et al.), which pays at any contrast; a ductile one gains from the geometric hardening alone, 32 % at most. The ranking holds on elements of 0.25 mm (24 %, P = 10 mm, H/P up to 0.15): the failure strains move by 1.9 points at most, the gains of the graded and brittle rules by 5 points at most; the ductile bound, whose failure is the necking alone, gains less there (+22 % instead of +32 % at the martensite: the strains of necking depend on the mesh, §4).

  3. The process limits bind. Every best feasible corrugation lies on the limit (H/P = 0.15 at P = 10 mm, the point of the grid below 0.169), and the failure strain rises further beyond it (the martensite: 18.0 % at H/P = 0.2, a radius of 1.27 mm, 24.3 % at 0.25). The longer period does not help in this gauge: its track leaves the 5 mm before its curvature limits it. A smaller heated width (tighter curves) or a wider specimen would open the rest of the maps.

  4. The fraction acts in opposite ways on brittle and ductile reinforcements. With the martensite (graded), the best feasible corrugation gains 83 % at 12 % (P = 15 mm, H/P = 0.15) at no cost of strength, 55 % at 24 %, 16 % at 36 %, and loses 8 % at 48 %: a wide brittle track cracks at its edges (above). A ductile reinforcement of the same contrast gains 9, 32, 66 and 75 %: more reinforcement to unbend.

  5. The energy, and the contrast as a lever of its own. The matrix alone absorbs 133 MJ/m³ up to its necking (its law of exponent 0.24): only reinforcements that do not break before the sheet necks absorb more. Within the limits the most energy goes to a reinforcement of intermediate contrast: graded, c = 3, 48 %, P = 10 mm, H/P = 0.15, 146 MJ/m³ (+10 % over the matrix, +11 % over the reinforcement alone) at R_m = 717 MPa (+30 % over the matrix); the ductile bound reaches 165 MJ/m³ (c = 4.64, 36 %), the martensite 81 MJ/m³ at most (12 %). On the front of strength and failure strain (figure, d), straight tracks of rising contrast lie on either side of a corrugated knee (c = 3, 48 %, H/P = 0.15): at equal strength a straight track of a softer reinforcement fails later than a corrugated martensite (graded, 24 %: straight at c = 3.5, 695 MPa and 17.2 %, against the martensite at H/P = 0.15, 693 MPa and 12.6 %). Tempering the track competes with corrugating it when a softer state is tougher (the graded rule); under the brittle bound the corrugated martensite wins (7.9 % for the straight track at c = 3.5). The toughness of the states between the matrix and the martensite decides, and is to be measured.

the failure strain and the energy against the height over the period for four contrasts, the infeasible designs shaded; the gain of the best feasible corrugation against the contrast under three rules of fracture; the tensile strength against the failure strain of every feasible design, coloured by contrast

6. Cellular design: the loop of SCOLASTIC

SCOLASTIC planned the patterns as the output of a loop: a cellular-automaton generator on a grid of 1 mm cells (the laser increment, a volume that carries a homogenized behaviour), finite elements of the load case, a local rule of the BESO type with multigrid acceleration, several treatment levels. :mod:morphogen.laser.cells builds it:

  • Cells and phases. CellGrid over the parallel part (the end columns continue to the grips: the blank is treated before the specimen is cut); Phase: a flow law, a critical strain, a cost (0 untreated, 1 treated; the levels of a multi-level treatment between); a design is an array of phases, or of densities for two phases. CellProblem evaluates it (the tensile test with the fracture of §5) for an objective (energy to failure, ductility, tensile_strength, strength_ductility) under constraints on the others.

  • Sensitivities by replay. A test records the deformation gradients of the Gauss points; replay integrates them again with another law: the work and plastic strains each element would have had in another phase, the kinematics held (it returns the external work within 3·10⁻⁵ with the same laws). A cell switched changes the force by the derivative of its replayed work; it breaks where its own replayed strain (with its neighbours’) reaches the critical one; the weakest cross-section of cells caps the strength (a gap in a track necks there). These estimates of every move cost a few tenths of a second.

  • Automata. beso with moves="swap": the BESO rule (benefits filtered and averaged over iterations, phases chosen by a Lagrange multiplier on the budget, levels of a multi-level treatment changing one at a time; Huang & Xie 2007, 2010), each new design at the budget tested by finite elements and refused, halved, then frozen if it lowers the value. moves="exchange": the phases of two neighbouring groups of cells exchanged — a track that bends or shifts at a constant budget (a Kawasaki rule) — the best estimates tested. Cells change by orbits of a symmetry and of the period of the pattern; min_width keeps the designs a spot of that many cells draws (treatable); multigrid solves coarser cells first (Abdalla, Kim & Gürdal 2004; Zakhama et al. 2009).

What the automata found, on cells of 0.5 mm, the phases of §5, at a constant treated share, for the failure strain with R_m ≥ 700 MPa (examples/laser_cells.py, §3):

start, rule

tests

R_m (MPa)

failure

straight track, 1 mm (20 %)

709

0.079

corrugated track P 10 H 1.5 drawn by a 1 mm spot (30 %)

705

0.120

its exchange automaton, treatable, periodic

41

719

0.165

flanks straightened, crests hollowed

its BESO rule, treatable

4

700

0.152

its BESO rule, any width

18

698

0.229

thin steep flanks, heavy crests

exchange automaton from the straight track

1

709

0.079

nothing to gain

exchange automaton, any width (a first try: from P 10 H 1.5 rasterized at 20 %, for R_m A)

133

638

0.228

islands, corner contacts

designs of cells of 0.5 mm (martensite dark) and their engineering curves to failure

Four findings shape the method:

  1. The straight track is stationary. Every local move of it is estimated neutral (the strain field is uniform) and is worse when tested (a kink is a notch); the benefit of corrugation is a threshold in H/P (§5, and the paper). Neither an automaton nor a gradient leaves it: the loop starts from a corrugation (or from a global search over its parameters, optimize).

  2. The pattern is periodic. A periodic track fails at its weakest period: a cell improved in one period moves the failure to the next. Cells change by orbits of the period and of the half-turn.

  3. The spot sets a minimum width. Without it the automaton breaks the track into islands and corner contacts that carry no load (and cannot be drawn): the strength falls to that of the matrix (638 MPa) while the failure strain rises.

  4. The replays rank, the finite elements decide. The replays hold the kinematics: they miss the redistribution of strain that a protrusion or a gap causes (a cell added beside a track is estimated +0.5 MJ/m³ and is −2.3). Testing the best few moves keeps only the true gains.

The best treatable design keeps the strength of the corrugated track and gains 37 % of failure strain; the unconstrained one (BESO, 0.229 at 698 MPa) points further: thin, steep flanks that unbend easily and carry little strain, heavy crests along the load that carry the strength — a track whose width varies along its path, which the power or the speed of the beam can modulate.

Tracks of variable width. The idea checked on its own (smooth tracks, the width varying linearly with the slope from the crests to the flanks, the same treated area, elements of 0.25 mm, 24 % as in the paper):

track

crest / flank width (mm)

R_m (MPa)

failure

energy (MJ/m³)

P 10, H 1.5 (sample 6)

1.00 / 1.00

685

0.125

72

1.30 / 0.90

704

0.141

84

1.40 / 0.80

713

0.169

104

1.50 / 0.70

702

0.169

103

1.80 / 0.50

665

0.136

78

P 15, H 1.5 (sample 4)

1.10 / 1.10

733

0.104

63

1.40 / 0.90

730

0.113

70

1.60 / 0.75

694

0.092

54

At H/P = 0.15, crests 40 % wider than the flanks gain 4 % of strength and 35 % of failure strain together, the energy to failure 44 %; flanks thinner than about 0.7 mm lose it again, and the gentler corrugation (0.1) gains little. A beam slowed down or strengthened at the crests draws such a track; the process model’s cycles are those of a constant beam, so that the realized widths remain to be computed along the path.

7. Topology optimization by densities

hca (the hybrid cellular automaton of Tovar et al. 2006: each cell’s stimulus, averaged over its neighbourhood, drives its density towards the set point of the budget) and topology (SIMP-like mixing of the flow stresses by x^q, density filter, Heaviside projection, MMA; Bendsøe 1989; Amir 2017 for two plastic phases) take the derivatives of the value from replays at x ± 0.05. From the same corrugated start they return it (R_m 701 MPa, failure 0.116 and 0.114): derivatives at fixed kinematics see the strength a cell adds, not the strain it moves onto the martensite next to it. The redistribution needs the adjoint of the path-dependent problem (Michaleris, Tortorelli & Vidal 1994; Alberdi et al. 2018), a storage of every state and a backward solve per step — not implemented; the tested automaton of §6 replaces it. (The voxel topology optimization of morphogen.optimization — OC, MMA, BESO, HCA — is the linear-elastic counterpart for periodic cells with voids; here both phases are solid, have the same Young’s modulus, and only plasticity and fracture differ, so that compliance sensitivities vanish.)

8. From cells to laser paths

design_tracks turns a design into the centre lines of its tracks (the midpoints of the runs of treated cells of each column, linked across columns; cross=True crosses the runs longer than the spot end to end, so that a square spot covers every cell — a real track, wider than the spot, then treats too much: 44 % instead of 34 % below), CellGrid.stamp draws polylines with a spot; a SheetCase with the pattern {"kind": "polylines", "tracks": ...} treats them with the process model (fibre and diode beams, metallurgy of the annealed MS1500). Every design above is one continuous track:

design

treated

R_p

R_m

A_g (%)

straight track

0.28

495

848

8.3

corrugated P 10 H 1.5

0.32

372

735

16.4

exchange automaton

0.34

376

752

17.2

The gain of the automaton survives the process (strength and elongation, the latter by Considère: the process model has no fracture by default — its partly transformed zones need their own critical strains, SheetMaterial.fracture, a table of hardness).

10. Other load cases: a crack, a corner, the anisotropy

SCOLASTIC proposed three applications beyond the tensile test: controlling the plastic anisotropy of the sheet, forming, and steering or blunting cracks. morphogen.laser.structures adds the structures (meshes of structured blocks graded towards the singular points, a displacement-controlled test, the initiation of a crack where a phase reaches its critical plastic strain, averaged within the phase over 0.5 mm), and CellProblem takes them as cases: the automata of §6 apply. Phases of §5 (annealed steel, martensite); the critical strain of the ductile matrix at a crack tip, 0.5, is an assumption (about half its fracture strain in tension), as are those of the hard sheets below.

Compact tension (CompactTension: ASTM E399 proportions, W = 20 mm, a/W = 0.5, 1 mm; pins as stars of bars that turn freely — the elastic load-line compliance within 2.5 % of Saxena & Hudak 1978). The force, the load-line displacement and the work at the initiation, the treated share of a 12 × 10 mm box around the tip:

hard tracks in the annealed steel

treated

force (kN)

displacement (mm)

energy (J)

initiation

none

0

0.95

1.94

1.54

tip, matrix

band 1 mm across the crack path, 1 mm ahead

0.12

1.27

2.23

2.27

the band breaks

band 2 mm, 1.5 mm ahead

0.12

1.28

2.70

2.76

tip

band 1 mm, 2 mm ahead

0.08

1.19

2.51

2.39

tip

band 1 mm, 4 mm ahead

0.04

0.99

2.02

1.65

tip

short barrier (`

y

< 2.5 mm`), 2 mm ahead

0.06

1.12

2.40

bands along the crack, y = ±1 mm

0.36

0.96

1.57

1.27

tip

A hard band across the path of the crack, ahead of its tip, shields it: the tip of the matrix initiates later, at a 36 % higher force and with 79 % more energy for a band of 2 mm at 1.5 mm; closer or thinner, the band breaks first; it must cross the whole plastic zone (a short barrier does less), and bands along the crack confine the plasticity and lower the energy. The ranking does not hang on the assumed critical strain of the matrix: at 1.0 (a tougher matrix; the critical strain of ductile initiation depends on the triaxiality and the Lode angle, Neimitz et al. 2018), the untreated specimen initiates at 0.96 kN and 2.02 J, the band of 2 mm at 1.5 mm at 1.40 kN and 4.18 J (+107 %), the band of 1 mm at 2 mm with +87 %, the bands along the crack with −36 %. In hard sheets softened by the laser the rules turn over (the configurational forces of a crack meeting a change of yield strength: Simha et al. 2005; Kolednik et al. 2011; Sistaninia & Kolednik 2014 — a crack running into a harder region is shielded, into a softer one anti-shielded):

hard sheet, softened bands

force (kN)

displacement (mm)

energy (J)

DP1180 (critical 0.25), none

1.85

0.77

1.03

tempered band 1.5 mm around the tip (0.40)

1.82

0.82

1.07

tempered band 1.5 mm, 2 mm ahead

1.73

0.74

0.94

tempered bands along the crack, y = ±2 mm

1.79

0.95

1.28

AA6082-T6 (critical 0.20), none

0.55

0.64

0.25

softened band around the tip (60 HV, 0.35)

0.55

1.00

0.41

softened band, 2 mm ahead

0.50

0.63

0.22

softened bands along the crack

0.46

0.95

0.33

A soft band ahead of the tip draws the crack (anti-shielding); the tip inside a soft band, or soft bands beside the crack that take the plasticity (the “relief zones” of Kahrimanidis et al. 2015 for forming), raise the energy of initiation at nearly the same force: by 24 % in the DP1180 with bands beside the crack, by 66 % in the AA6082-T6 with its tip in a softened band. The rules of thumb: hard ahead of a soft tip, soft around a hard tip, never soft ahead. The automata of §6 (1 mm cells) found no local improvement of the hard band at 2 mm: a local optimum. From an untreated sheet, the BESO rule (the budget raised to 10 % by 1 % per iteration, 34 tests) builds a chevron of hard cells 2 to 5 mm ahead of the tip: +15 % of energy, a poorer optimum than the straight band placed by hand (+55 % at 8 %) — the automaton refines, the designer’s rule starts it. So far the initiation; the growth of the crack follows.

Guiding the crack (SCOLASTIC: a spiral path, longer than a straight one, spending more energy). The crack now grows (CompactTension(propagate=True); theory: an element breaks when the averaged plastic strain of its phase reaches the critical one, the specimen is rebalanced at the same displacement — unstable growth as it comes — on a box of uniform elements of 0.25 mm over the ligament). The annealed steel (critical strain 0.5 at a crack tip), a spiral about the tip (pitch 3 mm, walls 1 mm wide, two turns: 20 % of the box), or three straight bands 1 mm wide across the ligament (12 % of the box); the work and the length of the crack at a load-line displacement of 10 mm, the work at 15 mm:

tracks

work to 10 mm (J)

crack at 10 mm (mm)

work to 15 mm (J)

none: a straight crack

5.25

7.8

6.22

spiral of martensite walls (critical 0.075)

4.78

9.5

5.66

the same, pitch 4 mm, walls 1.5 mm

4.41

9.8

4.89 (separated at 12.7 mm)

spiral track of martensite 0.5 mm wide (a brittle path)

4.78

9.3

5.72

spiral of hard walls, critical 0.2

5.57

7.8

6.60

the same, critical 0.5

6.16

7.0

7.69

the same, unbreakable

6.58

6.0

8.54

straight bands across, martensite

5.90

11.5

6.90

the same, critical 0.2

7.68

8.5

9.03

the same, critical 0.5

8.70

7.5

10.46

the same, unbreakable

9.77

7.0

12.67

The opening of a CT specimen does not let the crack turn: it keeps the straight line of mode I, cuts brittle walls (the martensite breaks at 7.5 %: less work than without tracks) and, when the walls hold, starts again in the matrix behind each of them — the walls left as bridges across the crack, holding its faces together (figure: the force after the crack has passed, twice that of the untreated specimen). The spiral works as a set of bridges, not as a path (+25 % of work to 10 mm with unbreakable walls); straight bands across the ligament, their whole length across the opening, bridge better (+86 %, the maximum force +42 %). The gain follows the toughness of the tracks: bands that break at a plastic strain of 0.2 (a tempered or low-carbon martensite) give +46 %, at 0.5 +66 %, the brittle martensite of the annealed MS1500 +12 %: hard tracks that do not break, rather than a longer path, are what spends the energy. To steer the crack along a curve the walls would have to hold the opening over the whole corridor: a curvature much gentler than a spiral of a few millimetres, or a loading in mixed mode. Limits: the elements break one by one (a crack one element wide, the averaging radius of 0.5 mm), a membrane (no shear lips, nothing out of the plane), critical strains assumed.

the paths of the crack of a CT specimen, untreated, with a spiral of martensite walls, with a spiral of unbreakable hard walls and with unbreakable bands across the ligament, and the force against the load-line displacement

L-shaped plate (LPlate: 40 mm, arms 16 mm, 1 mm, held along its top edge, the end of its arm pulled down 6 mm; the largest force up to there — the strength, the force still rising slowly as the matrix hardens):

hard tracks

treated

force at 6 mm (kN)

none

0

1.05

outer edges

0.08

1.20 to 1.24

no fracture

inner edges, through the re-entrant corner

0.05

1.10

the martensite breaks at the corner at 2 to 3 mm

block of 8 mm around the corner

0.05

1.13

BESO from the outer edges

0.08

1.32

flanges of the vertical arm, 2–3 mm off the corner

Hardening raises the limit load by a quarter with 8 % of the plate treated when the martensite stays away from the stress concentration: the brittle phase at the corner breaks first. (The automaton is kept off the held and pulled edges, whose uniform displacements it otherwise reinforces.)

plastic strain at the tip of a CT specimen without and with a hard band ahead of it, the curves to initiation, the BESO design of the L-shaped plate and its curves

Plastic anisotropy (SCOLASTIC’s first application). With directions=(0, 45, 90) the tensile tests give, besides the yield and tensile strengths, Lankford’s coefficient r of each direction (the width strain over the thickness strain at 10 % or before necking: 1.000 for the untreated sheet, isotropic von Mises), the normal and planar anisotropies r̄ = (r0 + 2 r45 + r90)/4, Δr = (r0 − 2 r45 + r90)/2 and Hill’s 1948 coefficients from the r values (hill48; F, G, H, N = 0.5, 0.5, 0.5, 1.5 when isotropic); the objectives isotropy (of the yield strength) and flow_isotropy (of r). On the specimens of the thesis, 5 mm wide, a pattern of a few millimetres is a structure: their r depends on how many tracks the gauge holds and where. The anisotropy of the sheet is that of its periodic cell (loading={"kind": "cell"}: morphogen.laser.periodic, the lattice of the pattern, the macroscopic gradient among the unknowns, a uniaxial stress in any direction; checked against Hill’s r(α), the rule of mixtures of a laminate and the curve of the untreated sheet). Annealed MS1500, martensitic tracks:

pattern

treated

r 0/45/90, specimens

r 0/45/90, the sheet

r̄

Δr

R_p 0/45/90, the sheet (MPa)

spread of R_p

one family along 0°, 2.5 mm apart

0.53

1.00 / 0.95 / 0.15

1.00 / 1.58 / 0.04

1.05

−1.06

783 / 357 / 395

0.83

crossed ±30°, 5 mm

0.46

1.06 / 0.77 / 0.33

1.25 / 0.39 / 0.56

0.65

+0.52

506 / 500 / 367

0.30

crossed ±45°, 5 mm

0.46

0.69 / 0.72 / 0.68

1.85 / 0.28 / 1.85

1.07

+1.57

377 / 522 / 377

0.34

honeycomb, side 3 mm

0.45

0.96 / 0.80 / 0.57

0.79 / 0.95 / 0.85

0.89

−0.13

450 / 442 / 430

0.05

The tracks set the anisotropy of the sheet over a wide range, by their structure: a family holds the width of the sheet pulled across it (r90 = 0.04: the soft layers between the tracks in plane strain) and lets it shear along them at 45° (r45 = 1.58: a shear does not thin the sheet); crossed families do the same about their bisectors (at ±45°, r0 = r90 = 1.85 and r45 = 0.28); the honeycomb is nearly isotropic, in yield (within 5 %) and in r (0.79 to 0.95). The narrow specimens tell otherwise — the crossed tracks at ±45° looked isotropic on them (Δr = −0.03), the tracks across them seemed to restrain the width less: the anisotropy of an architectured sheet is computed on its cell, or measured on specimens many periods wide. (The isotropic yield strengths optimized on specimens in the first version of this study, crossed tracks within 8 to 11 %, are the specimens’.)

The anisotropy of an architecture. Wang et al. (2023) pulled their corrugated tracks along their axis; the cell pulls them in every direction. Sine tracks along x, 5 mm apart (period P, height H), on an isotropic sheet (the annealed MS1500), every 15° (figure): the architecture alone sets the anisotropy, continuously. Straight tracks (27

their corrugation lowers the first and raises the second: at H = 1.5 mm the yield strength falls evenly from 388 to 337 MPa, at H = 2 mm it stays within ±6 % in every direction (345 to 386 MPa), at H = 3 mm the anisotropy has turned over (strongest at 45°, 420 MPa, weakest along the tracks, 370 MPa); shorter periods even it at a smaller height (P = 5 mm, H = 1.5 mm: 383 to 411 MPa, 43 % treated). Along the tracks the corrugation raises the uniform elongation from 8.6 % (straight) to 15.4 % (H = 1.5 mm): the geometrically induced work hardening of Wang et al. 2023, the tracks straightening as the sheet stretches — paid off the axis (6.1 % at 60°). Lankford’s coefficient follows the phase of the neighbours as much as the shape of a track: in phase, r0 = 1.31; shifted by a quarter period, 1.34; mirrored (the tracks closing into cells), r0 = 1.80 for r90 = 0.67 — a normal anisotropy out of an isotropic steel, as a texture would give it. The architecture is a texture that can be drawn; the next paragraphs use it against a rolling texture.

the yield strength, the uniform elongation and Lankford's coefficient of an isotropic sheet with sine tracks against the direction, for heights 0 to 3 mm and three phases of the neighbours

A rolled sheet, compensated (the aim: start from a sheet with a rolling texture and treat it to compensate its plastic anisotropy). A cold-rolled and annealed low-carbon steel has the γ fibre ({111} planes in the sheet) and Lankford coefficients of the order of r0 = 1.6, r45 = 1.2, r90 = 2.0 (Ray, Jonas & Hook 1994): r̄ = 1.5, good for deep drawing, and Δr = +0.6, four ears at 0° and 90° in a drawn cup. SheetMaterial.anisotropy gives them to the untreated steel through Hill’s 1948 criterion in plane stress, fitted to them (theory: the return mapping, its tangent, the axes of the texture turning with the material). A track transforms the steel; its martensite forms from austenite with a weak texture, isotropic here, or inherits a share memory of the sheet’s (the texture of a fast-heated steel survives its double transformation in part: Ray & Jonas 1990; Petrov, Sidor & Kestens 2012 above 1000 °C/s, the heating rates of a laser track). The texture given to the annealed MS1500, on the cell of the sheet (elements of 0.25 mm, 0.125 mm for the walls of the honeycombs; r at 10 % or 0.8 A_g; the spread of r, max − min over the mean, at 0°/45°/90°):

rolled sheet, treated by

treated

r 0/45/90

r̄

Δr

spread of r

R_p 0/45/90 (MPa)

A_g min (%)

nothing

0

1.59 / 1.20 / 1.97

1.49

+0.58

0.49

294 / 345 / 308

16.6

tracks along RD, 5.6 mm apart

0.24

1.41 / 1.67 / 0.40

1.29

−0.77

1.09

461 / 373 / 376

8.9

tracks along RD, 10 mm

0.13

1.49 / 1.60 / 0.91

1.40

−0.40

0.51

376 / 359 / 344

11.4

tracks along RD, 14 mm

0.09

1.52 / 1.50 / 1.15

1.42

−0.17

0.26

350 / 354 / 334

12.6

tracks along RD, 20 mm

0.07

1.54 / 1.41 / 1.36

1.43

+0.04

0.13

332 / 351 / 326

13.7

tracks along RD, 28 mm

0.05

1.55 / 1.35 / 1.51

1.44

+0.19

0.14

320 / 349 / 321

14.4

tracks along TD, 10 mm

0.13

0.81 / 1.46 / 1.79

1.38

−0.16

0.72

326 / 357 / 391

11.5

square grid along RD and TD, 10 mm

0.25

0.90 / 1.80 / 1.12

1.40

−0.79

0.71

406 / 376 / 430

8.1

square grid turned 45°, 10 mm

0.25

2.33 / 0.68 / 2.97

1.66

+1.97

1.15

320 / 456 / 334

5.9

grid: along RD every 24 mm, along TD every 39 mm (optimized, below)

0.09

1.34 / 1.43 / 1.45

1.41

−0.04

0.08

333 / 354 / 342

12.0

honeycomb, two sides along RD, side 5 mm

0.28

1.36 / 1.39 / 1.60

1.43

+0.09

0.17

360 / 411 / 373

6.4

honeycomb, side 4 mm

0.35

1.33 / 1.20 / 1.43

1.29

+0.18

0.18

386 / 437 / 396

5.2

honeycomb, side 3 mm

0.45

1.16 / 1.07 / 1.20

1.12

+0.11

0.12

444 / 492 / 445

4.2

The tracks act by their structure more than by the texture they erase. Along the rolling direction, they hold the width of the sheet pulled across them (r90 falls: the steel between them in plane strain) and let it shear along them at 45° (r45 rises: a shear does not thin the sheet) — both lower Δr, as a γ-fibre steel needs; sparse, they yield in compression and hold less. One track every 20 mm, 7 % of the sheet, brings Δr from +0.58 to +0.04 and the spread of r at 0°/45°/90° from 0.49 to 0.13, keeps r̄ (1.43) and most of the ductility (A_g 13.7 %), and evens the yield strength (spread 0.08 instead of 0.16). The same tracks along the transverse direction lower r0 instead (the wrong way here), a square grid along RD and TD raises r45 too much, the same grid turned 45° triples Δr (+1.97): the orientation of the pattern on the texture decides. A honeycomb with two sides along RD adds the isotropy of its network to the erasing of the texture: at 0°/45°/90°, r within ±6 % with 45 % of the sheet treated, Δr = +0.09 with 28 % (keeping r̄ = 1.43). Had the tracks kept the texture (memory = 1), those along RD would compensate as well (14 mm: Δr −0.14 instead of −0.17), the honeycomb of 3.5 mm less (spread 0.16 instead of 0.09): the structure first, the erased texture second.

The whole profile. Three directions are not the sheet (figure): over 0° to 90° every 15° (directions=range(0, 91, 15)), the untreated sheet spreads r over 0.51 (from 1.20 at 45° to 1.97 at 90°). The tracks along RD 20 mm apart bring it to 0.35 only: they compensate Δr, not the profile — they hold the width of the sheet from 60° on (r = 1.07 at 60°), where the texture raises r from 75° on. The honeycombs, nearly isotropic at 0°, 45° and 90°, peak at 75° (r = 1.56 to 1.96; a network of period 60° has not the harmonics of the texture): 0.43 to 0.50. A second family along TD, sparser, lowers r0 too and flattens the profile further: the Bayesian optimization of the two spacings over the whole profile (at most 25 % treated; cells of 0.5 mm, 18 evaluations) finds tracks along RD every 24 mm and along TD every 39 mm — 9 % of the sheet, r from 1.19 to 1.45 over 0°–90° (spread 0.20 instead of 0.51, on cells of 0.25 mm; 0.08 at 0°/45°/90°), Δr = −0.04, r̄ = 1.41, the yield strength within 6 % (333 to 354 MPa). The tracks along RD alone, as sparse, leave 0.28 to 0.31 (25 to 35 mm apart). A specimen 5 mm wide hardly sees the tracks along RD (figure, d): r90 = 1.80 against 1.35 for the sheet.

the cell of a rolled sheet treated by a grid of tracks along the rolling and transverse directions; Lankford's coefficient and the yield strength of the sheet against the direction for the untreated sheet, tracks along the rolling direction, the honeycomb and the optimized grid; a narrow specimen against the sheet

The price of the compensation is small for the sparse tracks: a few per cent of the sheet treated, r̄ kept near 1.4 (the drawability of the γ fibre), the yield strength up by 5 to 15 % and evened, the uniform elongation down from 16.6 % to 12 to 14 % along the axes — 6.3 % at 30° for the grid, where its cells localize the strain. Hill’s quadratic criterion, fitted to the r values, ties the anisotropy of the yield strength to them (the untreated sheet 15 % stronger at 45°): the yield strengths need a criterion of their own (below).

Yld2000-2d: the yield strengths too. Fitted to the r values, Hill’s criterion sets the yield anisotropy for them; a rolled sheet has its own. A DC04 (Banabic & Sester 2012): σ = 151, 166, 163 MPa at 0°, 45°, 90° and 192 MPa in equibiaxial tension, r = 1.83, 1.39, 2.11 (rb = 0.87, Hill’s r0/r90, not measured); Barlat’s Yld2000-2d (anisotropy={"criterion": "yld2000", ...}, exponent 6) fitted exactly to the eight (theory). Its texture given to the annealed MS1500, on the cell: r from 1.38 (45°) to 2.08 (90°), R_p from 294 (0°) to 330 MPa (60°) — spreads of 0.41 and 0.115 over 0°–90° every 15°. The tracks along RD strengthen the sheet most along them, where the DC04 is weakest: they even R_p (one track every 24 mm: spread 0.036; sine tracks 16 mm apart, P = 20 mm, H = 1 mm: 0.019, within ±1 %) — and in the same gesture hold the width of the sheet pulled across them, r falling at 60°–90° below its value at 45°: the spread of r grows again (0.45, 0.54). The two anisotropies of this texture are not compensated by one gesture. The designs evaluated by Bayesian optimization (tracks along RD, sine tracks along RD, grids along RD and TD; cells of 0.5 mm, both profiles over 0°–90°, at most 25 % treated) make a front (figure, a): sparse patterns lower both spreads together — a grid along RD every 35 mm and along TD every 52 mm, 7 % of the sheet: 0.27 and 0.073 (−35 % and −37 %), r̄ = 1.57 —; denser ones even R_p at the cost of r. With Hill’s criterion the yield anisotropy followed the r values and fell with them; with the yield stresses of the DC04, the structure that compensates the one works against the other. (Yld2000-2d at 0.25 mm: r within 2 % and σ within 0.7 % of the criterion in the cell, two Newton iterations a step.)

the spreads of r and of the yield strength over the directions for the designs evaluated on a DC04 texture, and the profiles of r and of the yield strength of the untreated sheet, of tracks along the rolling direction and of sine tracks

The sheet in its volume (morphogen.laser.solid, theory). The membrane is in plane stress, layer by layer. case_volume draws the periodic cell of the treated sheet as a voxel image for the solvers of three-dimensional fields: the hardness that the laser path leaves in each layer sorted into classes, each a phase with the flow law of its hardness (as von Mises plasticity: Voce’s law exactly, the power laws fitted within 1.5 %), and a gap of void voxels above the sheet, so that its two faces are free. The image is a microstructure like any other: its tensile test by the nonlinear FFT solver (volume_tension), its fields across the thickness, its other properties (homogenize), a conforming mesh.

from morphogen.laser import SheetCase, case_volume, volume_tension

case = SheetCase(
    material="annealed_ms1500",
    element=0.25,
    loading={"kind": "cell"},
    pattern={"kind": "straight", "angle": 0.0, "count": None, "spacing": 6.0},
)
image, materials = case_volume(case)  # 8 x 24 x (4 + 2) voxels, phases by hardness
print(image.metadata["hardness"])  # {1: 167, 2: 444, 3: 504} HV
along = volume_tension(image, materials, axis=0, strain=0.03)  # along the tracks
across = volume_tension(image, materials, axis=1, strain=0.03)
print(along["stress"][-1], across["stress"][-1])  # 760 and 589 MPa

On this cell (straight tracks 6 mm apart in a sheet of 1 mm, a fifth of it martensite) the volume and the membrane agree within 1.3 % along the tracks and within 3 % across them (true stresses up to 3 % of strain; the volume is the stiffer one across the tracks, where the membrane lets each layer thin as it flows), and the widths shrink alike (0.48 and 0.16 of the strain): the plane stress of the layers is a sound assumption for these sheets. Hard and soft halves side by side or one above the other follow the mean of their two laws within 3e-4. The volume is in small strains and has no fracture criterion: it complements the membrane (fields through the thickness, stresses across the tracks, other physics on the same image), it does not replace its tensile test up to necking.

11. Alternative materials

sheet_material("22mnb5"): the boron steel of hot stamping as delivered (75 % ferrite, 25 % pearlite, 185 HV: R_p about 400, R_m 520 MPa, A_g 18 %) hardened by martensitic tracks (up to 550 HV: 1150 and 1590 MPa; Karbasian & Tekkaya 2010; Merklein et al. 2006) — the steel of the laser-patterned crash tubes of Kim & Yoon (2021). sheet_material("aa6082_t6"): an age-hardened aluminium alloy softened by the laser (PeakSoftening: the hardness lost as a function of the peak temperature, the largest loss of the cycles kept — overaged near 350 to 400 °C, down to 60 HV for good; dissolved above about 480 °C, then naturally aged back to about 80 HV; Myhr & Grong 1991; the alloy and the treatment of the tailor heat-treated blanks of Piccininni & Palumbo 2020), with the elasticity of aluminium. Through the whole chain:

sheet, track

R_p

R_m

A_g (%)

treated

22MnB5 1.5 mm, none

397

521

17.5

0

straight (200 + 150 W)

416

557

15.8

0.03

corrugated P 10 H 1.5

409

556

16.1

0.04

AA6082-T6 1 mm, none

288

331

6.8

0

softened straight (2 × 260 W, 20 mm/s)

174

256

10.7

0.48

softened corrugated P 10 H 1.5

125

223

12.9

0.53

The boron steel behaves as the annealed MS1500, with a thicker sheet that needs more power: the track of 200 + 150 W hardens only 3 % of 1.5 mm, to 504 HV at most. The aluminium alloy turns the logic over: the laser softens it, trading strength for ductility (as T6 for T4), and its diffusivity spreads the track: a single track of 1.5 mm softens half of the 5 mm gauge — architectures of aluminium have features of a few millimetres, not one; the soft bands ahead of or around a crack (§10) are its use. Titanium alloys (Ti-6Al-4V: α’ martensite after laser heating above the β transus, gas nitriding of the surface) and magnesium are not modelled.

12. Use

from morphogen.laser import Beam, SheetCase, Specimen, optimize

case = SheetCase(
    material="annealed_ms1500",
    specimen=Specimen(kind="dogbone", length=30.0, width=5.0, thickness=1.0),
    beam=Beam(power=150.0, speed=10.0, radius=0.5, absorptivity=0.55),
    bottom=Beam(power=100.0, speed=10.0, radius=0.6, absorptivity=0.55, profile="tophat"),
    configuration="symmetric",
    pattern={"kind": "corrugated", "count": 1, "amplitude": 1.0, "period": 15.0},
)
result = case.evaluate()
print(result.measures["tensile_strength"], result.measures["uniform_elongation"])

best = optimize(
    case,
    {"pattern.amplitude": [0.0, 2.5], "pattern.period": [6.0, 30.0]},
    objective="strength_ductility",
    constraints={"yield_strength": [400.0, None], "min_radius": [1.5, None]},
    method="bayesian",
    evaluations=30,
)
print(best.values, best.objective)
print(best.result.path.to_gcode())  # the laser path of the optimum

Bending and directions are options of the case: loading={"kind": "bending", "span": 30.0, "deflection": 1.0} with a Specimen(kind="strip", ...), and directions=(0, 45, 90) (the measures are then the means, yield_strength_45… each direction’s, and yield_anisotropy, strength_anisotropy, elongation_anisotropy).

Cellular designs (§5–§8):

from morphogen.laser import CellProblem, SheetCase, beso, design_tracks, wang_phases
from morphogen.laser.cells import corrugation

problem = CellProblem(
    phases=wang_phases(),  # ferrite and brittle martensite (§5)
    size=0.5,  # cells of 0.5 mm
    objective="ductility",  # the failure strain...
    constraints={"tensile_strength": [700.0, None]},  # ...at R_m >= 700 MPa
)
start = problem.grid.stamp(corrugation(problem.specimen, 1.5, 10.0))  # a 1 mm spot
run = beso(
    problem,
    start,
    budget=None,
    moves="exchange",
    symmetry=("point",),
    period=10.0,
    min_width=2,
    candidates=6,
)
print(run.summary())
tracks = design_tracks(problem.grid, run.design)  # the laser path that draws it
case = SheetCase(pattern={"kind": "polylines", "tracks": [t.tolist() for t in tracks]})
print(case.evaluate().measures["tensile_strength"])

Structures and directions (§10):

from morphogen.laser import CellProblem, FlowLaw, SheetCase
from morphogen.laser.cells import Phase
from morphogen.laser.structures import CompactTension, LPlate

phases = (
    Phase("ferrite", FlowLaw.hollomon(280, 986, 0.24), critical=0.5, cost=0),
    Phase("martensite", FlowLaw.hollomon(1300, 1966, 0.06), critical=0.075),
)
ct = CellProblem(
    phases=phases,
    case=CompactTension(max_disp=5.0),
    size=0.25,
    fracture_radius=0.5,
    objective="energy",
)
band = ...  # an array of the cells of ct.grid (1: martensite)
print(ct.evaluate(band).measures)  # failure_strain: the initiation (load-line / W)
sheet = SheetCase(
    pattern={"kind": "crossed", "angle": 45.0, "spacing": 5.0}, directions=(0, 45, 90)
)
m = sheet.evaluate().measures
print(m["r_value_0"], m["r_bar"], m["delta_r"], m["hill_n"])

A rolled sheet and its compensation (§10), on the periodic cell of the sheet treated all over:

from dataclasses import replace
from morphogen.laser import SheetCase, sheet_material

rolled = replace(
    sheet_material("annealed_ms1500"), anisotropy={"r0": 1.6, "r45": 1.2, "r90": 2.0}
)  # + "memory": 0..1
sheet = SheetCase(
    material=rolled,
    element=0.25,
    pattern={"kind": "honeycomb", "cell": 3.0},
    loading={"kind": "cell"},  # the cell of the lattice of the pattern
    directions=(0, 45, 90),
)
m = sheet.evaluate().measures
print(m["r_value_0"], m["r_value_45"], m["r_value_90"], m["r_anisotropy"], m["r_bar"])

Yld2000-2d (yield stresses and Lankford coefficients of a DC04) and the growth of a crack (§10):

from dataclasses import replace
import numpy as np
from morphogen.laser import CellProblem, FlowLaw, SheetCase, sheet_material
from morphogen.laser.cells import Phase
from morphogen.laser.structures import CompactTension

dc04 = {
    "criterion": "yld2000",
    "s0": 151,
    "s45": 166,
    "s90": 163,
    "sb": 192,
    "r0": 1.83,
    "r45": 1.39,
    "r90": 2.11,
    "rb": 0.87,
    "a": 6,
}
rolled = replace(sheet_material("annealed_ms1500"), anisotropy=dc04)
sheet = SheetCase(
    material=rolled,
    element=0.25,
    loading={"kind": "cell"},
    pattern={"kind": "straight", "angle": 0.0, "count": None, "spacing": 60.0},
    directions=tuple(range(0, 91, 15)),
)
print(sheet.evaluate().measures["yield_anisotropy"])

ct = CompactTension(
    max_disp=15.0, fine=0.25, refine=(4.0, 20.0, 9.0), propagate=True, region=(4.0, 20.0, -9.0, 9.0)
)
phases = (
    Phase("ferrite", FlowLaw.hollomon(280, 986, 0.24), critical=0.5, cost=0),
    Phase("hard wall", FlowLaw.hollomon(1300, 1966, 0.06), critical=float("inf")),
)
problem = CellProblem(phases=phases, case=ct, size=0.25, fracture_radius=0.5)
walls = ...  # an array of the cells of problem.grid (1: hard), e.g. along a spiral
result = problem.evaluate(walls).result
broken, at = result.fields["broken"]  # the elements of the crack, in their order
print(np.trapezoid(result.force, result.displacement) / 1000)  # the work (J)

The cellular section of a configuration takes a structure too (case: {kind: ct, max_disp: 5} or {kind: l_plate, region: [0, 34, 0, 36]}, phases with their critical strains, a start of tracks).

examples/laser_sheets.py runs the studies of §2–§4 (about three minutes), examples/laser_cells.py those of §5–§8 (about five minutes), examples/laser_contrast.py the maps of the strength contrast of §5 (about ten minutes on 16 processes, its results in a CSV file and the figure with --figure), examples/laser_morphologies.py, examples/laser_crack_paths.py (--map: the map of steering) and examples/laser_stiffness.py the studies of §14 (about twenty, ten and one minutes on 16 processes; examples/laser_architecture_figures.py draws their figures), examples/laser_geometric_hardening.py those of §15 (about fifteen minutes on 16 processes, --study one of them, stiffness in a file of its own; examples/laser_geometric_hardening_figure.py draws the figures), examples/laser_networks.py those of §16 (--study directions, forming and mk, in files of their own: about fifteen, twenty and one minutes on 16 processes; examples/laser_networks_specimen.py the dog-bones of §16.4, examples/laser_networks_figure.py the figure), examples/laser_drawing.py those of §17 (--study mk, grooves, limits, shear, tension and uniaxial, in files of their own; the grooves are refined about their least limit by a second run; hours on 18 processes for the corrugated cells; examples/laser_crossed_specimen.py the dog-bones, gathered by examples/laser_crossed_specimens_table.py, examples/laser_crossed_mechanism.py the stress along the tracks, examples/laser_cell_fields.py the snapshots of the cell, examples/laser_corrugation_fine.py the corrugations about θ*, examples/laser_fraction_inverse.py the treated fraction and the switched phases, examples/laser_drawing_figure.py the figure), examples/laser_structures.py those of §10–§11 (about half an hour), examples/laser_cracks_and_textures.py the DC04 texture, the growth of the crack and the sine architectures of §10 (about fifty minutes); the template laser_cells runs the automaton of §6 and treats its tracks from the command line (cellular section of the configuration, about a minute).

morphogen template laser_corrugated -o laser.yaml
morphogen laser laser.yaml            # results/ laser.json, curves, history, G-code, maps
morphogen laser laser.yaml --no-optimization

13. Limits and next steps

  • Heat: constant properties and no latent heat (a peak above the solidus marks melting, not a temperature); the absorptivity is calibrated (0.42 for 430 under argon after Wang et al., 0.55 for the annealed MS1500 on the 1.2 mm tracks); the cycles of a point are those of a long straight track (curvature radii above the heated width; ends outside the specimen); the tracks cool between them (the transient solver gives the heat they leave otherwise).

  • Metallurgy: Maynier’s formulas are for low-alloy steels; no kinetics of carbon homogenization in austenite (the superheat stands for it); the peak-temperature table of 430 is phenomenological; no grain size, no residual stresses or distortion.

  • Mechanics: a membrane (no bending of a sheet treated on one face), isotropic von Mises plasticity (no anisotropy of rolling), perfect bonding of the tracks (the volume of §10 solves the three-dimensional fields of the periodic cell, in small strains and without fracture; its cell stays flat); fracture is the critical plastic strain of a brittle phase averaged over 1.5 mm, fitted to one test (the straight track of Wang et al.) and checked on five; the process model’s partly transformed zones have no fitted fracture yet (with one, its corrugated tracks break too early); the strains after necking depend on the mesh.

  • Contrast: the states between the matrix and the martensite interpolate the Hollomon parameters (a partly transformed or tempered track, not computed by the process model); their toughness is the critical strain of the martensite over the square of the share (graded), between the bounds brittle and ductile, to be measured (tensile tests of sheets treated at several energies, or of tempered tracks). The matrix of Wang et al.’s law necks at 26 % (the annealed sheet at 16.7 %): the failure strains of the designs that do not break follow that law.

  • Bending: small deflections, no membrane force, no shear of the beam; the layers discretize the section (four layers: 6 % less stiffness than the continuous one).

  • Cellular design: the estimates of the replays hold the kinematics (they rank the moves, finite elements decide): the automata are local searches from a corrugation, not global ones; the derivatives of hca and topology miss the redistribution of strain — the adjoint of the path-dependent problem (Michaleris, Tortorelli & Vidal 1994) is the next step for gradient methods; the minimum width is a square spot on the grid, not the heat-affected width of the process.

  • Structures: the crack grows by broken elements (a band one element wide; the path follows the mesh where the strain allows; the averaging radius of 0.5 mm sets the scale), critical strains assumed for the matrices, the hard phases and the hard sheets (the toughness of the tracks decides the bridging: to be measured), no shear lips nor out-of-plane bending of the crack faces; no residual stresses (those of laser heating retard fatigue cracks in aluminium); pins as rigid stars; the limit load of the L-shaped plate in plane stress (no buckling of the thin arms).

  • Anisotropy: Hill’s quadratic criterion ties the anisotropy of the yield stress to the Lankford coefficients it is fitted to; Yld2000-2d takes both, its rb and exponent assumed for the DC04 (no biaxial test); no kinematic hardening nor evolution of the texture with the strain; the texture of the tracks is a share of the sheet’s (memory), to be measured (EBSD); the periodic cell tests the sheet under uniaxial stress, direction by direction (the earing of a cup needs a forming simulation), with a membrane: the hard tracks it compresses (those along the rolling direction in a test across them) cannot buckle; its nonlocal fracture average stops at the edges of the cell. Specimens narrower than a few periods measure a structure, not the sheet.

  • Materials: the 22MnB5 and AA6082-T6 presets come from handbook properties, the softening table of the aluminium alloy is generic (a minimum of overageing near 400 °C, natural ageing after dissolution), not fitted to tests of laser tracks.

  • Next: tracks of variable width (power or speed modulated along the path: the unconstrained optimum of §6 asks for thin flanks and heavy crests); several levels of treatment (the tempering of martensitic sheets of SCOLASTIC, with data: Lapouge et al. 2019; the contrast of §5 realized by the power, the speed or a second pass, with the toughness of each state); designs of the periodic cell by the automata of §6 (symmetries imposed, Alberdi & Khandelwal 2020) and the earing of a drawn cup from the whole profile of r; a criterion of the rolled sheet fitted to its yield stresses as well (Yld2000-2d, Barlat et al. 2003); formability (Marciniak–Kuczyński) and fatigue load cases; light alloys (precipitation-hardened aluminium: Shercliff–Ashby, Myhr–Grong; the laser softening of AA6082 of Piccininni & Palumbo 2020); calibration against the DIC fields of the thesis.

14. Architectures at the scale of the spot

The concept. A laser that treats a sheet through its thickness by spots of 1 mm² turns a sheet of a few tens of centimetres into a canvas of 10⁴ to 10⁵ independently treated areas: the morphology of a two-phase (or multi-phase) sheet becomes a design variable, at a scale two to three orders of magnitude below the structure, as in the architectured materials of Bouaziz, Bréchet & Embury (2008) and Bréchet & Embury (2013). The spot sets the smallest feature, 1 mm × 1 mm, not a grid: a track follows any curve. The designs are therefore drawn on cells of 0.5 mm and opened by a square spot of two cells (morphogen.laser.architectures.spot_opening), so that every treated cell lies in a treated square of 1 mm². morphoGen’s 2D morphological models supply the vocabulary of shapes; this chapter asks which of them make a sheet stronger, more ductile, more isotropic or more tolerant of a crack, and what the material pair allows. In a laser-treated steel the phases differ by their plastic flow and their toughness, hardly by their stiffness (§14.4): the architectures of a steel sheet are plastic architectures.

14.1 The morphologies of morphoGen at 1 mm. Sixteen designs on a periodic cell of 24 × 24 mm (examples/laser_morphologies.py; figure, a): the laser patterns of this module (straight, corrugated and crossed tracks), and morphoGen’s 2D models: hexagonal and Voronoi honeycombs (honeycomb), their complement (hard cells, soft walls), nacre (nacre, bricks), a Gaussian excursion set (gaussian_excursion), Boolean discs (sections of boolean_spheres), a Turing pattern (activator_inhibitor), a conserved coarsening automaton (cellular_automaton), Wang tiles of pipes (tile_assembly), a planar Delaunay fibre network (delaunay_network), a random laminate with holes (random_laminate), Johnson–Mehl grains (nucleation_growth, continuous nucleation stopped early) and a meta-polycrystal (the grains of a 2D Voronoi tessellation, each filled with tracks of its own random direction). Every one is treatable after the opening; the measures of the treatment (treatment_measures) sort them. Untreated pixels next to the treatment, in its heat-affected zone, are 20 to 50 % of the untreated area in most designs, but 86 to 88 % for the soft walls of the complement and of nacre: walls 1 mm wide between treated areas lie wholly in the heat of their neighbours and may not stay soft. At a third of the sheet treated, a beam of 1 mm at 10 mm/s treats a sheet of 300 × 300 mm in 0.5 to 0.9 h of beam time (pauses between neighbouring tracks aside), 1.9 h at three quarters.

14.2 The sheet. Each design repeated over a sheet (sheet_tests: the periodic cell pulled at 0°, 45° and 90°, morphogen.laser.periodic), the phases of §5: the matrix of Wang et al. and, treated, either the as-quenched martensite (brittle, critical strain 0.072) or a tempered one (contrast_phases(3), critical strain 0.24). The yield strength in the three directions, the tensile strength (mean), the failure strain in the three directions and the energy to failure (mean, MJ/m³):

design

treated

R_p 0/45/90, martensite

R_m

failure (%), martensite

energy

failure (%), tempered

energy

untreated

0

301 / 301 / 301

552

26.8 / 26.8 / 26.8

135

fully treated

1

1327 / 1327 / 1327

1558

6.9

99

14.1

135

straight tracks

0.33

517 / 317 / 338

732

8.3 / 30.3 / 18.3

119

20.7 / 29.3 / 19.4

140

corrugated tracks

0.38

383 / 338 / 325

689

8.3 / 20.5 / 16.7

91

20.8 / 18.0 / 18.2

112

random laminate

0.32

473 / 316 / 335

702

5.3 / 29.3 / 14.4

98

20.0 / 22.8 / 17.1

118

crossed tracks

0.31

411 / 322 / 411

736

7.4 / 19.4 / 7.4

73

20.9 / 26.3 / 20.9

138

hexagonal honeycomb

0.28

347 / 332 / 353

662

10.6 / 10.3 / 7.9

55

20.2 / 18.9 / 21.6

116

Wang tiles (pipes)

0.19

345 / 311 / 344

601

5.7 / 13.0 / 5.9

42

20.0 / 23.4 / 19.5

116

Voronoi walls

0.32

354 / 346 / 352

632

5.5 / 5.6 / 5.3

29

15.1 / 17.3 / 16.2

92

Delaunay fibre network

0.37

384 / 357 / 378

657

4.9 / 4.7 / 4.1

25

12.0 / 15.3 / 15.6

83

Gaussian excursion

0.31

336 / 325 / 330

597

9.6 / 12.6 / 8.2

53

12.3 / 14.9 / 11.0

68

Boolean discs

0.36

335 / 330 / 333

586

8.1 / 8.3 / 8.3

42

9.7 / 11.8 / 9.4

54

Turing pattern

0.34

336 / 326 / 332

604

9.2 / 13.8 / 10.9

60

13.1 / 15.5 / 13.3

76

coarsened automaton

0.35

342 / 333 / 333

612

6.3 / 8.1 / 8.8

41

13.6 / 14.7 / 11.0

72

Johnson–Mehl grains

0.32

326 / 323 / 329

583

11.6 / 13.5 / 8.8

58

13.3 / 14.1 / 10.4

66

meta-polycrystal

0.29

332 / 335 / 326

609

8.1 / 11.2 / 12.8

57

12.9 / 15.9 / 16.2

81

nacre (bricks)

0.56

413 / 336 / 368

688

9.3 / 14.8 / 9.3

68

16.3 / 15.1 / 10.6

86

Voronoi cells, soft walls

0.75

416 / 398 / 416

644

3.2 / 4.7 / 3.1

20

3.4 / 4.8 / 3.2

21

sixteen designs drawn by morphoGen's 2D models on a cell of 24 mm, the tensile strength against the least failure strain of the sheets they make, and the spread of the yield strength over the directions against the energy to failure, for the as-quenched and the tempered martensite

Four rules come out of the table, independent of the model that draws the design:

  1. Strength needs a hard phase connected along the load. Isolated hard islands (Boolean discs, the Gaussian excursion, the Turing pattern, the automaton, Johnson–Mehl grains), a third of the sheet, raise the yield strength by 7 to 14 % only: the soft matrix percolates and yields first, at its own stress, the islands adding hardening (R_m +6 to +11 %). Tracks along the load raise it by 72 % (517 MPa), networks by 3 to 37 % depending on the direction (the honeycombs and the Voronoi walls by 10 to 18 % in every direction).

  2. A connected hard phase must be tough. With the as-quenched martensite, the networks break at 4 to 8 % in their weakest direction (Voronoi walls 5.3 %, Delaunay fibres 4.1 %) and the tracks along the load at 8.3 %, the strain of §5; the same networks of a tempered martensite reach 12 to 21 % in their weakest direction, the honeycomb and the Wang tiles about 20 % in every direction. The architecture of a steel sheet and the toughness of its hard phase are designed together: as in §5, a treatment that leaves the hard phase tougher (a tempered track, a level of a multi-level treatment) is worth more than a harder one.

  3. Thin soft layers across the load localize. Hard cells in soft walls 1 mm wide fail at 3 to 5 % whatever the toughness of the cells: the strain gathers in the walls (nacre, with more mortar, at 9 to 16 %). A soft phase thinner than a few spots must not cut the load path; in nacre the toughening of a natural composite needs weak interfaces that a laser-treated steel does not have (as in the Mg–Ti composites of Zhang et al. 2022, where brick and mortar is the least tough).

  4. Isotropy costs strength unless the network carries it. The meta-polycrystal is isotropic (yield within 3 %, Lankford’s coefficient within 13 to 19 %) but no stronger than the islands (its tracks are cut at the grain boundaries, and the matrix percolates between them); the hexagonal honeycomb and the Wang tiles are isotropic within 6 to 10 % and, tempered, absorb 116 MJ/m³ at R_m = 606 to 628 MPa. Along the tracks, straight tracks of tempered martensite make the strongest and most ductile of the tempered sheets (444 MPa, 19 to 29 %, 140 MJ/m³, more than the untreated sheet with its law of exponent 0.24), with the anisotropy of §10.

14.3 Steering a ductile crack. The crack of a compact tension specimen (W = 30 mm, examples/laser_crack_paths.py) grows by the breaking of the elements (the matrix at an averaged plastic strain of 0.5, §10), with a design of 1 mm over its ligament (figure). In a hard sheet (contrast_phases(c), graded) a soft corridor 2 mm wide from the tip, at an angle to the crack, takes it from c = 3 on: the crack runs in the corridor (72 to 94 % of its broken elements) and turns with it up to 60° (the direction of the crack and its share in the corridor, corridors 2 mm wide, elements of 0.5 mm):

corridor

c = 2

c = 3

c = 4

15°

10.6° (82 %)

11.5° (94 %)

13.4° (93 %)

30°

18.7° (71 %)

24.0° (83 %)

19.8° (82 %)

45°

3.1° (24 %)

38.8° (82 %)

31.5° (72 %)

60°

−2.9° (27 %)

66.3° (93 %)

59.3° (83 %)

work to separation, 60° (J)

20.6

20.2

18.0

fully treated (J)

24.0

10.8

14.6

On elements of 0.25 mm the crack follows the corridors of c = 3 and 4 as closely (21.7°, 34.9° and 60.3° at 30°, 45° and 60° for c = 3; 20.2° and 58.3° at 30° and 60° for c = 4; 69 to 100 % in the corridor), but no longer those of c = 2 (3.6° at 30°, 40 % in the corridor): the drift of the coarse mesh at c = 2 is an artefact of the erosion, and the threshold of steering lies between c = 2 and 3. The strength mismatch decides, as in welds, where a ductile crack drifts towards the softer material (Minami et al. 1995; Nègre, Steglich & Brocks 2005): a corridor of the matrix in a sheet three times as strong leads the crack up to 60° from the path of mode I. Corridors 1 mm wide steer as well (62.7° and 64.4° at 60°, c = 3 and 4), corridors 3 mm wide less at large angles (not at 60° for c = 3). The cost depends on the angle: a corridor near the path of mode I lets the crack through for less work than the hard sheet (6.5 against 10.8 J at 15°, c = 3), a steep one makes it run in mixed mode, longer, for more (20.2 J at 60°, +87 %): a corridor can lead a crack where it does least harm, or make it spend more. Turning a crack further takes a gentle curve: an arc of 8 mm radius turning by 90° held it over its first part only (63 to 66 % of the crack in the arc at c = 3 and 4) before the crack left it along the path of mode I, and a corridor that ends after 6 mm deflects the crack, which then crosses the tough hard sheet straight (no arrest). Hard walls along a corridor in the untreated sheet do not steer (the crack crosses or passes them, 21 to 43 % in the corridor), consistently with §10 (the CT opening keeps the crack in mode I and the hard walls act as bridges); staggered hard bricks halve the work (0.53 of the untreated sheet): the crack runs in the mortar. The rules of thumb of §10 extend to growth: a soft path in a tough hard sheet guides the crack; hard features in a soft sheet bridge or blunt it; thin soft layers attract it. Kolednik’s soft interlayers across the path (Sistaninia & Kolednik 2014, 2017) are the complementary design: a soft band crossed by the crack shields it once crossed.

the paths of the crack of a CT specimen through designs of 1 mm (untreated, soft corridors at 30 and 60 degrees in a hard sheet, an arc, a corridor that ends, hard walls, bricks, Voronoi walls), the direction of the crack against the angle of the corridor for three contrasts, and the force against the opening

14.4 Stiffness. The phases of a laser-treated steel share Young’s modulus: the martensite is about 3 % below the ferrite–pearlite (Kim & Johnson 2007), the nitrides and carbides of carburized or nitrided layers no stiffer than ferrite (γ′-Fe4N about 160 GPa), the austenite within a few per cent. morphoGen’s FFT homogenization of the designs (examples/laser_stiffness.py, a plane-stress stiffness condensed from the periodic cell) puts every steel sheet between 205.5 and 208.8 GPa, isotropic: a stiffness architecture in steel can only come from the geometry of the sheet or from the residual strains of the tracks (the eigenstrains that program buckled shapes in metallic glass ribbons, Li et al. 2022). Two systems have a laser-switchable modulus through the thickness of a sheet: a metastable beta titanium aged then solution-treated by the laser (Ti-15V-3Cr-3Sn-3Al: 107 to 111 GPa aged, 82 GPa solution-treated; laser stiffness gradients in aged beta alloys: da Costa et al. 2020), and NiTi, superelastic austenite at about 68 GPa against martensite at 25 to 40 GPa in tension, made martensitic at room temperature by laser pulses that evaporate nickel (Khan, Pequegnat & Zhou 2013; Šittner et al. 2014). With the designs of §14.1: beta titanium sheets of 88 to 103 GPa (spread over the directions 2 % at most), NiTi sheets of 37 to 57 GPa, the straight tracks anisotropic by 13 % with Poisson’s ratio from 0.30 to 0.36. Elastic architectures are realistic in NiTi (nonlinear and temperature dependent), structural but weak in beta titanium; the treated fraction, a gradient over the sheet, is their main lever.

14.5 Materials to test. The largest property contrasts through the thickness of a sheet come from transformations that complete within the dwell of a laser (a survey of 88 references):

material and treatment

contrast

why

annealed C–Mn–B steel (MS1500, 22MnB5): martensite and tempered martensite

R_m 594 / 920 / 1523 MPa; essential work of fracture 212 / 130 / 38 kJ/m² (Garcia-Llamas et al. 2023)

three levels in one sheet, the toughness that rules 2 and §14.3 ask for; process mastered at PIMM

cold-rolled metastable austenitic steel (301, 301LN) with laser reversion

yield ≥ 965 MPa and 9 % (full hard) against 300 to 1000 MPa and up to 43 % (reverted at 700 to 1000 °C for 1 to 100 s: Somani et al. 2009; Järvenpää et al. 2020)

no quench, no hardenability limit; reverted austenite paramagnetic in a ferromagnetic matrix: the architecture read by magnetic imaging (Leskovšek et al. 2016)

aged metastable beta titanium (Ti-15-3) with laser solution treatment

yield 965–1172 → 770 MPa, 5–7 → 22 %, E 107–111 → 82 GPa

the only structural alloy with a modulus contrast through the thickness

NiTi strip, laser nickel depletion or local annealing

E about 68 against 25–40 GPa; superelastic, shape memory and elastic domains in one strip (Meng et al. 2012)

an elastic and functional demonstrator

The aluminium alloys are poor candidates: the laser only dissolves or overages their precipitates, by 30 to 35 % at most, the dissolved state re-ageing at room temperature; AA2024-T3 loses at most 20 % of its hardness and 3 % of its strength, and cracks when it melts (Kashaev et al. 2021), which accounts for the unsuccessful trials at PIMM. Its documented use is the residual stress of laser heating lines (+285 % of fatigue crack growth life). For a feature of 1 mm, the time of diffusion across half a millimetre is about 0.04 s in steel and 0.004 s in aluminium: an aluminium sheet spreads the heat sideways as fast as through its thickness (softened zones of about 5 mm).

14.6 A demonstrator. The results above make a programme of three sheets. (1) An annealed MS1500 sheet of 300 × 300 × 1 mm with three levels (untreated, tempered and as-quenched martensite), treated with zones of straight and corrugated tracks (directional strength and ductility), of a honeycomb or Wang tiles of tempered tracks (isotropic strengthening at about 20 % of failure strain) and of soft corridors in a tempered field ahead of notches (CT or SENT specimens cut from the sheet, a crack led at 30° to 60°), tested with DIC in the directions of §10 and on crack paths (examples/laser_demonstrator.py, figure: 40 % of the sheet treated, about 1 h of beam time at 10 mm/s with a spot of 1 mm, the pauses between neighbouring tracks aside). (2) A cold-rolled 301LN sheet with reverted tracks, the same designs read magnetically during loading. (3) A NiTi strip with an elastic gradient. Steps of the model: the toughness of the tempered states (the graded rule of §5 to be measured), the heat-affected zone of the process model on the designs (the soft walls of rule 3), a ductile damage law with the triaxiality (Rice–Tracey, GTN) in place of the critical strain for the crack paths (element erosion biases them towards the mesh: Pandolfi, Weinberg & Ortiz 2021), and the residual stresses of the tracks.

a sheet of 300 by 300 mm in four zones, straight tracks, a hexagonal honeycomb and Wang tiles of tempered martensite with dog-bones at 0, 45 and 90 degrees, and a tempered field with soft corridors from the notches of compact tension blanks at 0, 30 and 60 degrees next to an untreated blank

15. Geometric work hardening in one laser-treated steel

The idea. A corrugated reinforcement in a matrix that flows first bends at its crests, then straightens towards the load: it turns from an ineffective orientation to an effective one, and the composite hardens by its changing geometry when its materials alone no longer would (geometrically induced work hardening; Bouaziz 2013). Fraser et al. (2014, 2018a, 2018b, 2020) built it with two metals, a copper matrix (E 115 GPa, yield stress 25 MPa, K 540 MPa, n 0.53) and a 4130 steel reinforcement (207 GPa, 350 MPa, 1200 MPa, 0.12), and charted when it pays (in sections of a laminate, plane strain): the reinforcement must stay nearly elastic while its crests bend (a yield stress above a threshold), and the matrix must neither neck before the corrugation has straightened nor harden so much that the boost comes too late (a window of its yield stress over its hardening). Wang et al. (2023) obtained it in one steel, laser martensite in annealed MS1500, with one track in the 5 mm gauge of a dog-bone (§4, §5), where the height over the period stays below 0.15, short of the threshold of Fraser et al. (a height peak to trough of 0.35 period, H/P = 0.175 here). Two questions: which contrast between the phases unbends the corrugation, their stiffness or their strength; and what a sheet of tens of centimetres, free of the gauge, allows (examples/laser_geometric_hardening.py, morphogen.laser.architectures.track_membrane: smooth tracks over a periodic cell, phases of different moduli, a treatment that changes along a track).

15.1 Which contrast unbends the tracks. A contrast of Young’s moduli makes the stresses heterogeneous at a given strain, and the strains at a given stress, but only while the phases are elastic: once a phase yields, its stress follows its flow law, whatever its modulus. The matrix of the steel yields at a strain of 0.13 % (280 MPa over 210 GPa), the martensite at 0.6 %, and the geometric hardening plays out between 5 and 40 %. Over that range the contrast of current stiffness is that of a track still elastic, its Young’s modulus, against a matrix that flows, its hardening (2140, 1310 and 790 MPa at 5, 10 and 20 % in the annealed MS1500): a ratio of about 100, 160 and 270, and 180, 250 and 340 for the copper and steel of Fraser et al. The plasticity of the matrix makes this contrast, and the strength contrast keeps the tracks elastic while it lasts. The study stiffness tests it at 24 % of martensite, P = 20 mm and the ductile rule (the necking isolated): the modulus of the tracks from 70 to 630 GPa at fixed flow laws, a matrix of 70 GPa, and moduli in a ratio of 3 with the matrix’s flow law in both phases (the stiffness contrast alone); the proof stress is read on the initial slope of each curve (third figure, c):

moduli, matrix and tracks (GPa)

modulus of the sheet, straight / H/P 0.25 (GPa)

R_p0.2, straight / 0.25 (MPa)

uniform elongation, straight / 0.2 / 0.25 (%)

energy, H/P 0.25 (MJ/m³)

210 and 70

175 / 156

324 / 312

16.9 / 28.8 / 31.0

187

210 and 117

187 / 181

369 / 319

16.7 / 28.3 / 30.5

185

210 and 210 (one steel)

210 / 210

464 / 327

16.5 / 28.0 / 30.2

184

210 and 420

263 / 246

567 / 336

16.4 / 27.7 / 30.1

184

210 and 630

315 / 268

571 / 340

16.4 / 27.7 / 30.1

184

70 and 210

105 / 89

567 / 332

16.9 / 28.3 / 30.7

185

210 and 630, one flow law

315 / 268

299 / 301

26.8 / 26.8 / 26.8

135

70 and 210, one flow law

105 / 89

291 / 299

27.4 / 27.4 / 27.4

137

  1. The modulus of the tracks hardly moves the geometric hardening. From 70 to 630 GPa, a factor of 9, the uniform elongation of the corrugated sheet falls by 0.9 point (31.0 to 30.1 % at H/P = 0.25) and its energy by 2 %, while the corrugation adds about 14 points to the straight tracks at every modulus; the softer tracks gain their larger elastic strain (σ_y/E: 1.9 % at 70 GPa, 0.2 % at 630 GPa). A softer matrix adds its own elastic strain, 0.4 point at 70 GPa (the 117 GPa of Fraser’s copper in the ratio of his steel: 16.7 and 28.1 % at H/P = 0.2; figure, d).

  2. The modulus acts at the start of the curve. It sets the modulus of the sheet (the rule of mixtures along straight tracks, less with corrugated tracks, which bend) and the proof stress of straight tracks, from 324 to 571 MPa: a stiffer track takes its share of the load at a smaller strain, a softer one is still elastic at the offset of 0.2 %. Corrugated tracks carry little at that stage, and their proof stress moves less (312 to 340 MPa).

  3. Without a strength contrast, nothing is left beyond the elastic range. With one flow law, moduli in a ratio of 3 either way give the untreated sheet’s uniform elongation and energy (26.8 to 27.4 %, 135 to 137 MJ/m³), straight or corrugated; the extra 0.6 point with a matrix of 70 GPa is its elastic strain.

The partition of the stresses and the strains between the phases shows why (third figure, a and b: the mean axial stress of the treated material over that of the untreated, and the mean equivalent strain of the untreated over that of the treated, against the strain of the sheet). With one flow law and moduli in a ratio of 3, straight tracks carry 2.7 times the stress of the matrix (the ratio of 3 diluted by the mixed points at their edges), and around corrugated tracks the matrix strains twice as much as they do: the heterogeneity of the elastic range. It vanishes as the phases yield: beyond 1 % of strain both ratios stay between 1.0 and 1.15, the flow stress, the same in both, capping the stresses. With a strength contrast and one modulus, the ratios stay at 1 in the elastic range and grow once the matrix yields: corrugated tracks carry about twice the stress of the matrix from 10 % of strain on, while the matrix strains up to nine times as much as they do (at 5 %): they turn rather than stretch. Stiffer tracks (630 GPa) strain less still, twelve times less than the matrix at 5 %, but carry the same stress (a ratio of 2.0). The modulus of a track sets how much it stretches, its strength how much it carries, and the hardening of the sheet lies in what the tracks carry: while a corrugated track unbends, the force it transmits along the load is bounded by the plastic moment of its crests over its current height, σ_y t²/(4H) per unit thickness, which holds no modulus. A stiffness contrast would count where the reinforcement stays elastic over strains of the order of the slack (fibres in an elastomer, the crimped fibres of a tendon), not between metals, whose elastic strains stay near 1 %; the laser states of one steel differ in modulus by a few per cent, 10 % at most (the survey of §14, Table 2). The strength contrast does it all, and the laser provides it. In the charts of Fraser et al. (2020: linear hardening, a matrix yield stress of 300 MPa), the annealed MS1500 (Considère’s strain 0.235, a linear hardening of about 390 MPa at that yield stress) lies in the window where corrugation pays for a reinforcement above about 600 MPa: the laser martensite (1300 MPa) and its tempered states of a contrast above about 2.

15.2 What the sheet changes. A corrugation y = H sin(2π x/P) made by a track t = 1 mm wide has a slack, the strain that straightens it free, L/P − 1 (L its length over a period): 9 % at H/P = 0.1, 32 % at 0.2, 46 % at 0.25, 62 % at 0.3; its flanks start at atan(2π H/P) from the load (32°, 51°, 57°, 62°); its crests have a radius P/(4π² H/P), at least 1.5 mm to be treated (§5): H/P up to 0.17 at P = 10 mm, 0.34 at 20 mm, 0.51 at 30 mm. In a sheet the gauge no longer bounds the height, and the longer periods reach the whole range of Fraser’s charts. Straightened completely, a crest would bend its track by t/(2R): 10 % at H/P = 0.1 and 20 % at 0.2 for P = 20 mm, more than the as-quenched martensite takes (7.2 %).

15.3 The sheet of corrugated tracks. The periodic cell holds one period and one track, the tracks in phase, their spacing setting the treated fraction; cells of 2 × 2 to 4 × 4 periods with an imperfection of 0.5 % in one period give the same uniform elongation within 0.2 point (the failure strain of the most corrugated martensite 2 points lower), elements of 0.25 mm within 2.1 points (the strengths within 15 MPa). 24 % of martensite, R_m (MPa) / failure strain (%) / energy up to it (MJ/m³), under the two rules of §5 (ductile: the necking alone, the bound of the geometric hardening; graded: the as-quenched martensite breaks at 0.072, the fit to the tests of Wang et al.; figure, a to c):

design

ductile

graded

untreated sheet

552 / 26.8 / 135

552 / 26.8 / 135

straight tracks

783 / 16.5 / 121

764 / 8.3 / 57

P = 20 mm, H/P = 0.1

760 / 19.6 / 137

722 / 7.9 / 50

P = 20 mm, H/P = 0.2

703 / 28.0 / 179

652 / 10.4 / 57

P = 20 mm, H/P = 0.25

665 / 30.2 / 184

639 / 14.2 / 79

P = 20 mm, H/P = 0.3

632 / 27.5 / 160

627 / 19.5 / 109

P = 30 mm, H/P = 0.25

665 / 32.1 / 196

627 / 11.8 / 64

  1. The geometric hardening of one steel matches that of two metals. Ductile, the corrugation turns the early necking of the straight tracks (16.5 %) into a uniform elongation above the matrix’s from H/P = 0.2 on, with a tensile strength 20 to 27 % above it: the sheet is both stronger and more ductile than when untreated, the hole in property space of Fraser et al. (2018a). At 36 % (P = 30 mm, H/P = 0.25): 716 MPa, 39.4 % and 266 MJ/m³, twice the energy of the untreated sheet. The yield strength falls back near the matrix’s (459 MPa straight, 321 to 351 MPa corrugated): the corrugation trades yield strength for hardening, as Wang et al. measured.

  2. An optimum height, set by the slack. The uniform elongation peaks at H/P = 0.25 (a slack of 46 %) and falls at 0.3, where the boost comes after the matrix has necked (the bound foreseen by Fraser et al. 2018b). At a given H/P the period matters little (2 points at most up to 0.2). There is no threshold against the straight tracks, whose martensite necks early (unlike Fraser’s steel in copper); the corrugation passes the matrix’s uniform elongation at H/P ≈ 0.2.

  3. The strength contrast sets the size of the boost. Ductile, the best feasible design at 36 % absorbs 266, 180 and 151 MJ/m³ for contrasts of 4.64, 4 and 3 (straight tracks: 114, 126 and 135): the threshold of the reinforcement’s yield stress of Fraser et al. (2020) appears as a continuous trend.

  4. The as-quenched martensite breaks at the crests. Graded, the first fracture lies at a crest, where the track bends (a plastic strain of 0.09 to 0.17 there), while the flanks stay elastic: the tracks unbend rather than stretch, as the mechanism requires, but their hinges crack. The failure strain rises with the height (8.3 % straight, 19.5 % at P = 20 mm and H/P = 0.3), short of the matrix’s, and so does the energy (109 MJ/m³ against 135). A tempered reinforcement of contrast 3 (its critical strain 0.24 under the graded rule) does not break before the necking: 633 MPa, 25.6 % and 148 MJ/m³ at 24 % (P = 30 mm, H/P = 0.2), 676 MPa, 24.3 % and 151 MJ/m³ at 36 %, the energy 10 % above the untreated sheet at a strength 15 to 22 % higher. As in §5, the toughness of the treated states decides, and is to be measured.

15.4 A track treated differently along its path. Only the laser can soften a reinforcement where it bends: the crests treated at a lower energy (tempered, contrasts of 2 and 3) or left untreated, the flanks as-quenched (track_membrane with two treated phases). At 24 % and P = 20 mm (second figure, b), tempering the crests over a quarter of the period about each rescues the martensite: at H/P = 0.25 the failure strain rises from 14.2 to 26.4 %, at 628 MPa and 152 MJ/m³ (14 % stronger than the untreated sheet, 13 % more energy, nearly its failure strain), slightly beyond a track tempered all along (25.3 %, 618 MPa, 143 MJ/m³); at the other heights the uniform temper does as well or better. Over an eighth of the period, the softer hinge concentrates the bending and breaks itself at the crest (14.2 % at H/P = 0.2, 18.6 % at 0.25). Untreated crests leave pieces of oblique martensite (15 to 21 % of the sheet treated) and reach 21 to 23 %. The gain over the as-quenched track is large; the gain over a uniform temper is small, and rests like it on the toughness assumed for the tempered state.

15.5 Recruitment does not pay. Tracks of two to four heights in one cell straighten one after another, as the crimped fibres of a tendon, and spread the boost over a wider range of strain. Ductile, they reach 22.3 to 26.4 % at 24 %, below the best single height (30.2 %); graded they do worse (6.6 to 9.8 %), the least corrugated tracks straightening first and breaking. The boost pays when it is concentrated and timed to the necking of the matrix.

15.6 A check against Fraser et al. Their copper with 20 % of steel in the periodic sheet (second figure, a) (P = 8 mm, one reinforcement every 5 mm, its width keeping the fraction): necking strains of 40.5 % straight and 55.2 % at a height of 4 mm peak to trough, against their 40 % and about 55 % (Fraser et al. 2018b, Fig. 3a), and hardly any gain below a height of 2 mm (their threshold, h/P = 0.35). Their plane-strain sections and this plane-stress sheet agree on the necking strains; the stresses differ by the factor of plane strain.

15.7 Specimens. A dog-bone cut from the sheet holds tracks up to its edges, where the soft channels between them reach the free edge: the necking starts there (maps of the plastic strain). Ductile, at 24 % and P = 20 mm (second figure, c): 18.0 % at H/P = 0.2 with four tracks across the gauge (22 mm), 23.0 % with eight (44 mm), 28.0 % for the sheet; 21.4, 24.3 and 27.5 % at 0.3; the straight tracks match the sheet (16.7 and 16.4 % against 16.5 %). Graded, eight tracks give 8.2 and 14.8 % against the sheet’s 10.4 and 19.5 %. A border of tempered martensite 2 mm wide along each edge does worse (20.9 and 16.9 %): a straight hard band necks first. A test of the sheet needs specimens of eight tracks or more, read by DIC away from the edges, and the cut edges of a part are its weak points.

15.8 What to treat. A zone of the demonstrator of §14.6: corrugated tracks at P = 20 mm and H/P = 0.25 and 0.3 (crest radii of 2.0 and 1.7 mm), 24 and 36 %, as-quenched, tempered, and as-quenched with tempered crests (the power lowered over a quarter of the period about each crest); dog-bones of eight tracks or more (about 50 mm wide and 90 mm long) with DIC on the hinges, and the straight tracks and the untreated sheet for reference. The fracture of the hinges under bending, and of the tempered states, is the decisive unknown: the graded rule is an assumption.

Considère's plot of the untreated sheet, straight tracks and corrugated tracks of three heights; the failure strain against the height over the period for three periods under two rules of fracture; the tensile strength against the failure strain of straight tracks and of the best corrugations for three contrasts; the uniform elongation of straight and corrugated tracks under four contrasts of strength and stiffness the necking strain of copper with corrugated steel against Fraser et al.; the failure strain of corrugated martensite with softer crests; the uniform elongation of dog-bones of four and eight tracks against the periodic sheet the mean axial stress of the tracks over that of the matrix and the mean equivalent strain of the matrix over that of the tracks against the strain of the sheet, for a contrast of stiffness alone, of strength alone and of both, straight and corrugated tracks; the uniform elongation of straight and corrugated tracks against the ratio of the moduli of tracks and matrix

16. Where geometric hardening works: directions, networks, forming

The questions. The corrugated tracks of §15 harden the sheet along their axis, in uniaxial tension. A part is loaded in other directions too, and a sheet is formed along biaxial paths. Three questions follow: how the corrugated sheet behaves away from its axis; whether networks of corrugated tracks spread the effect over the plane; what happens along the paths of forming (examples/laser_networks.py, examples/laser_networks_figure.py). The designs treat 24 % of the sheet with tracks 1 mm wide, of as-quenched martensite (ductile and graded) or tempered (contrast 3, breaking at 0.24): one family (P = 20 mm, §15), a square network (two families along x and y, two tracks of each per period, the second a quarter of a period behind, so that the families cross instead of running along each other) and a triangular network (three families at 0, 60 and 120° through the nodes of a triangular lattice, one wave between two nodes; it is chiral, its directions repeat every 60° without mirroring), their period or side scaled so that the crossing tracks treat 24 % (23.7 and 20.5 mm at H/P = 0.25).

16.1 Away from the axis. The periodic sheets pulled in the directions of the plane (the angle from the tracks along x): the failure strain (%) with the ductile reinforcement, and the least and the largest energy to fracture (MJ/m³) and tensile strength (MPa) over the directions with the tempered one (the untreated sheet: 26.8 %, 135 MJ/m³ and 552 MPa in every direction; figure, a and b):

design, 24 %

0°

15°

30°

45°

60°

75°

90°

energy, tempered

R_m, tempered

straight tracks

16.5

17.6

22.2

35.3

23.3

16.4

18.2

97 to 157

576 to 664

corrugated tracks, H/P 0.25

30.3

14.6

11.8

16.1

16.6

19.3

18.2

93 to 143

606 to 625

square network, straight

17.7

17.1

22.2

26.7

22.2

17.1

17.7

122 to 152

620 to 643

square network, H/P 0.25

18.4

11.0

11.8

16.1

13.9

18.4

22.2

98 to 122

612 to 622

triangular network, straight

23.3

18.3

10.7

19.1

23.3

18.3

10.7

115 to 131

612 to 638

triangular network, H/P 0.25

17.1

19.5

14.7

16.1

17.1

19.5

14.7

109 to 121

614 to 618

  1. The corrugation pays along its axis only. 30.3 % at 0°, 14.6 % at 15° already, 12 to 19 % beyond: within 15° of the axis the gain turns into a loss.

  2. Straight tracks oblique to the load harden late. At 45° straight tracks reach 35.3 %, 674 MPa and 215 MJ/m³ (ductile), more than the corrugation along its axis, and the as-quenched martensite does not break there (35.3 % as well, against 8.3 % along the load). The sheet shears (freely, in the periodic cell) and holds its tracks on a line it hardly stretches, by 0.5 % at a strain of 15 % and 2.2 % at 30 %, while they turn by 13° towards the load; the straight tracks of §14.2 at 45° (30.3 %) showed the same effect. At 30° the tracks stretch from the start (6.3 % at 15 %), at 60° they are still unstretched at 30 %: 22.2 and 23.3 %.

  3. No network hardens geometrically, in any direction. With the ductile reinforcement the corrugated square network fails between 11 and 22 % depending on the direction and the triangular one between 15 and 20 %, below the untreated sheet; in every direction one family is stretched from the start (the flanks of the family along y lie at 33° from a load along x; the families at 60 and 120° run at 2.5° from x along part of their length). The triangular network of tempered tracks makes the most isotropic sheet (failure strains of 19 to 22 %, 109 to 121 MJ/m³, in every direction), 11 % stronger than the untreated sheet but not tougher.

16.2 The forming limits. cell_test(ratio=...) follows linear paths of the true strains, ln(1 + b) = ρ ln(1 + a), from plane strain (ρ = 0) to equibiaxial stretching (1), the stress along the major strain being the mean nominal stress of the cell (mean_nominal). The Marciniak–Kuczyński analysis is made in the cell: a groove 1 mm wide (the thickness of the sheet), normal to the major strain, its flow stress 0.5 % lower, across a cell of at least two periods and 60 mm. The limit is the strain outside the band of 1 mm that strains ten times faster than its images in the other periods (the groove, or a neck elsewhere: a neck breaks the periodicity of the pattern, whereas a band that strains faster in every period is a partition of the strains), the strain at which the path can no longer be followed (the rest of the cell unloading elastically as the neck softens), or the fracture of the reinforcement, whichever comes first. On the untreated sheet the groove in the cell gives the classical analysis (rigid plastic, von Mises, the Swift law of the matrix, the same imperfection: 0.190, 0.256, 0.397, 0.535 and 0.647 from ρ = 0 to 1) within 0.004 from ρ = 0.25 to 1 and 0.006 in plane strain, on cells of 50 to 200 mm (20 mm: up to 0.024 above; --study mk). The major true strain at the limit, ductile reinforcement (figure, c):

design, 24 %

ρ = 0

0.25

0.5

0.75

1

untreated sheet

0.195

0.256

0.397

0.537

0.650

straight tracks, major strain along them

0.128

0.145

0.176

0.198

0.211

straight tracks, across

0.118

0.138

0.183

0.241

0.294

corrugated tracks H/P 0.25, along

0.120

0.155

0.223

0.295

0.358

corrugated tracks, across

0.074

0.089

0.112

0.135

0.159

square network H/P 0.25

0.065

0.077

0.102

0.122

0.142

triangular network H/P 0.25, along x

0.077

0.087

0.110

0.214

0.234

triangular network, along y

0.074

0.081

0.123

0.198

0.252

  1. Every architecture lowers the forming limit on the stretching side: 0.07 to 0.13 in plane strain against 0.195, 0.14 to 0.36 in equibiaxial stretching against 0.65. The tempered reinforcement does little better (0.10 to 0.17 in plane strain, 0.15 to 0.28 in equibiaxial stretching; straight tracks along the major strain break at about 0.20 from ρ = 0.25 on). The necks form in the matrix along the hard tracks, along the flanks of a corrugation in plane strain.

  2. The corrugation does not unbend before it stretches. Along its axis it raises the limit over straight tracks on the biaxial side (0.358 against 0.211 at ρ = 1), where straight martensite stretches with the sheet and necks with its own low hardening, but not in plane strain (0.120 against 0.128); across its axis it is the least formable family (0.074 in plane strain).

  3. The networks are the least formable (0.065 to 0.077 in plane strain): the matrix enclosed in their cells is held in every direction.

16.3 The rule: lines that the deformation shortens. Under the homogeneous true strains ε1 and ρ ε1, a material line at an angle φ from the major strain stretches by (e^(2ε1) cos²φ + e^(2ρε1) sin²φ)^½ (figure, d). For ρ < 0 the lines beyond φ0 = atan (−1/ρ)^½ are first shortened, then turned towards the major strain, and stretched: 54.7° in uniaxial tension (ρ = −½, plastic incompressibility), 45° in a section in plane strain (ρ = −1, the sections of Fraser et al.); these are the directions of zero extension along which Hill (1952) placed the localized neck of a sheet. For ρ ≥ 0 no line is shortened: every line stretches from the start (by 16.2 % at a major strain of 0.15 in equibiaxial stretching, whatever its angle). A track along a shortened line carries little until it has turned, then takes the load: the boost of geometric hardening, late by the strain it takes to turn. The flanks of a corrugation lie at atan(2π H/P) from its axis: 54.7° at H/P = 0.225, 45° at 0.159. The rule accounts for the results of §15 and of this chapter:

  • at H/P = 0.25 (57.5°) the flanks are shortened up to a strain of 14.8 % in uniaxial tension, at 0.3 (62°) up to 45 %: the boost of the first comes before the matrix necks (26.8 %), that of the second after it, which makes the optimum and the decline of §15.3; below 0.225 the flanks stretch from the start, and a corrugated track reinforces like a weaker straight one;

  • the threshold of Fraser et al. (a height of 0.35 period peak to trough, H/P = 0.175, flanks at 47.7°) lies just beyond the 45° of their plane-strain sections, and their corrugations of 2 mm (flanks at 38°) hardly paid in §15.6;

  • off its axis, one flank of a corrugation is stretched from the start, whereas straight tracks oblique to the load lie on a line that the shearing sheet keeps unstretched (16.1);

  • whatever the direction of a uniaxial load, a network holds one family on stretched lines: the cone of shortened lines turns with the load, so that geometric hardening cannot be isotropic in tension;

  • the stretching side of forming (ρ ≥ 0) has no shortened line: no corrugation unbends before it stretches, and the tracks hold the matrix that necks along them.

16.4 Oblique tracks in a specimen. The periodic sheet shears freely; a dog-bone does not, and its edges cut the tracks (examples/laser_networks_specimen.py: gauges 44 mm wide and 90 or 180 mm long, straight tracks treating 24 %). Along the load the dog-bones match the sheet (16.2 and 17.4 % against 16.5 %, ductile; the as-quenched martensite breaks at 6.2 and 6.3 %). At 45° they reach 25.2 and 26.6 % (ductile), short of the sheet’s 35.3 %: each track ends at the free edges, where it can carry nothing along its length, and the longer gauge does not recover it. The as-quenched martensite at 45° still holds to 23.5 and 24.5 %, against 6.2 % along the load, at 650 MPa and 137 to 143 MJ/m³: 18 % stronger than the untreated sheet for the same energy (135 MJ/m³), with the hardest state of the laser and no temper. A part whose oblique tracks run on beyond the loaded zone comes closer to the periodic sheet than a narrow specimen, whose edges weigh as much as its tracks.

16.5 What it means. The corrugation of a laser track is a directional reinforcement: for a part loaded in uniaxial tension within a few degrees of the axis of its tracks, its flanks just beyond the line of zero extension (H/P about 0.25), and for the paths with ρ < 0 (the flange of a deep-drawn cup, near −1, where flanks beyond 45° suffice: a prediction, the inclined necks of that side not being computed here). Straight tracks oblique to the load (about 45°) harden late without a corrugation and spare the as-quenched martensite, which then needs no temper (16.4). On the stretching side of forming every architecture lowers the limit: a sheet to be stretched is treated after forming, or not where it is stretched. Isotropic strengthening comes from networks of tempered tracks (the triangular one: 11 % of strength, 19 to 22 % of failure strain in every direction), at a cost in energy, not from geometric hardening. The networks of wavy struts that give elastomers a J-shaped curve in every direction (Jang et al. 2015; Ma et al. 2016) rely on struts that bend elastically over strains of the order of their slack; in a metal sheet the matrix flows, and the kinematics of its flow decide which tracks carry.

the uniform elongation of straight and corrugated tracks and of square and triangular networks against the direction of the load, ductile reinforcement; their energy to fracture with the tempered reinforcement; their forming limits from plane strain to equibiaxial stretching against the untreated sheet and the classical Marciniak-Kuczynski analysis; the stretch of a material line against its initial angle for five strain paths

17. The drawing side, and crossed families that lock

The questions. On the stretching side of forming every architecture lowers the forming limit (§16.2), and the rule of §16.3 says why: no line of the sheet is shortened there. On the drawing side (ρ < 0) the lines beyond φ0 are first shortened, and the rule predicts that tracks laid there harden the sheet late; but the necks of that side are inclined (Hill 1952), and the limit is the least over the angle of the groove (Hutchinson & Neale 1978). Three questions: which designs raise the limit of the drawing side; whether an architecture can be drawn from the rule itself rather than from the corrugation; whether it survives the free edges of a specimen (examples/laser_drawing.py, examples/laser_crossed_specimen.py, examples/laser_crossed_mechanism.py, examples/laser_drawing_figure.py).

17.1 Inclined grooves in the cell. The groove runs along a vector g of the lattice of the pattern: any direction for straight tracks, which are invariant along themselves; for corrugated tracks and crossed families the vectors of their lattice, the shortest within 2° of the angle asked (from 15° for corrugations: nearer to the normal of their axis the vectors grow beyond 76 mm). The cell is the parallelogram that g spans with a vector of the lattice nearly normal to it, 60 mm across, meshed in rows along g (PeriodicCell.build(shape=...)); the groove is two rows, about 1 mm wide, 0.5 % weaker. The path of the strains is prescribed in full, the principal axes of the mean stretch held (cell_test(free_shear=False)), as by the tools of a press and in the classical analysis; the limit is the major strain outside the band of two rows that thins ten times faster than its images in the other periods (and than a tenth of the mean thinning of the cell: the images of a band inside a shortened hard track thicken), as in §16.2 but on the thickness strain, which an inclined neck concentrates whatever its shear. On the untreated sheet the cell follows the classical analysis of inclined grooves (rigid plastic, von Mises, the Swift law of the matrix, the same imperfection; mk_limit) within 0.007 at every angle and path, and its critical angle: the least classical limits are 0.358 at 21° in uniaxial tension, 0.294 at 21° at ρ = −⅜, 0.248 at 18° at −¼ and 0.214 at 13° at −⅛, the cell’s 0.362, 0.298, 0.253 and 0.219 on grooves by the degree; a cell twice as long (0.367 at 20°) or free to shear (0.367) changes nothing. A groove much beyond the critical angle does not localize: its normal turns with the sheet, tan ψ = e^((1 − ρ) ε1) tan ψ0, and it passes the line of zero extension before it necks.

17.2 Single families on the drawing side. The least limit over the grooves (24 %, ductile; untreated 0.362 and 0.253):

design, 24 %

ρ = −½

−¼

straight tracks at 0° from the major strain

0.214

0.162

at 30°

0.243

0.180

at 45°

0.288

0.201

at 60°

0.291

0.195

at 75°

0.225

0.173

at 90°

0.250

0.178

corrugated along the major strain, H/P 0.2

0.360

0.210

H/P 0.25

0.353

0.211

H/P 0.3

0.350

0.206

H/P 0.35

0.328

0.183

  1. Straight tracks lose at every angle. Of the two critical necks, symmetric about the major strain, one runs within about 10° of a family oblique to the load and follows its matrix: tracks at 60° stop the necks that cross them (no localization for grooves at +10 to +40°) but not the groove at −25° (0.291).

  2. The corrugation keeps the limit of the untreated sheet in uniaxial tension at best (0.35 to 0.36), and loses it towards plane strain, where its flanks lie within the cone of stretched lines (φ0 = 63.4° at ρ = −¼).

17.3 Crossed families: a scissor network. The rule asks for tracks along lines that the deformation first shortens, turning past the line of zero extension when the matrix would neck. Two families of straight tracks crossed at ±θ about the load lie both in the cone of shortened lines for θ > φ0, and the network is symmetric about the load, so that the sheet does not shear. Inextensible tracks would leave the sheet a mechanism: a mean stretch diag(λ1, λ2) keeps both families at their length when λ1² cos²θ + λ2² sin²θ = 1, the rhombic cells lengthening along the load as their sides turn (lazy tongs). The matrix contracts as λ2 = λ1^(−½) in uniaxial tension; for θ > φ0 the mechanism contracts less, the tracks hold the width of the sheet in mild compression while they turn, until both coincide at cos²θ = 1/(1 + λ + λ²), when the tracks reach the line of zero extension (the strain at which a line at θ recovers its length, §16.3): beyond, the network locks and its tracks take the load. Placing the locking at the necking of the matrix, λ = e^n, gives cos²θ* = 1/(1 + e^n + e^(2n)): 59.5° for n = 0.24. The periodic sheet pulled along the bisector (--study tension, each family at the spacing that treats 24 % together, 2t/s − t²/s² = f), R_m (MPa) / uniform elongation (%) / energy (MJ/m³):

θ

ductile

as-quenched (failure)

tempered (c = 3)

untreated sheet

552 / 26.8 / 135

45°

700 / 28.1 / 177

693 / 23.6 (20.5) / 125

629 / 26.9 / 154

55°

654 / 35.6 / 212

651 / 33.2 (29.0) / 168

608 / 28.5 / 159

57°

634 / 37.1 / 216

60°

606 / 42.9 / 245

605 / 42.8 (39.2) / 223

585 / 26.9 / 145

62°

607 / 23.4 / 131

607 / 23.4 / 131

65°

602 / 18.2 / 100

602 / 18.2 / 100

588 / 20.3 / 109

70°

610 / 16.7 / 92

610 / 16.7 / 92

594 / 18.5 / 100

  1. The best geometric work hardening of the periodic sheet, with straight tracks. At 60° the network beats the best corrugation (665 MPa, 30.2 %, 184 MJ/m³) in uniform elongation and energy, and the as-quenched martensite does not break before the sheet necks (8.3 % along the load). Elements of 0.25 mm: 41.7 % (ductile) and 40.4 % (as-quenched).

  2. A drop just beyond the angle of the rule. 39.3 and 42.9 % at 59 and 60°, 23.4 % at 62° and 18 to 20 % beyond (0.25 mm: 40.7, 41.7, 39.6 and 22.4 % at 59, 60, 61 and 62°): within 2.5° of θ*, which neglects the stiffness of the matrix in the mechanism. Beyond, the network locks after the matrix has necked, its tracks holding the sheet in compression (−605 MPa at 70°); below, it locks early. At 60° the mean stress along the tracks stays between −116 MPa and zero up to about 10 % of strain, then rises to 1118 MPa.

  3. The fraction and the contrast. 33.7 % at 60° and 12 %; at 36 % the optimum moves to 55° or below (37.3 %, 710 MPa, 246 MJ/m³), a denser network holding the contraction more. The tempered state gives 26.9 % at 60°: the boost follows the strength contrast, as for corrugations.

17.4 Specimens: the free edges. In a dog-bone 44 mm wide (gauge 90 mm; examples/laser_crossed_specimen.py), the network at 60° gives 606 MPa but 23.6 % of uniform elongation (21.7 % on 180 mm, the tempered state 23.1 and 21.7 %): the free edges cut the rhombic cells into open half-cells, which the tracks do not close, and the matrix necks there first while the closed cells of the interior remain held (map). A straight track along each edge makes it worse (17.1 %, ductile; 9.3 % with as-quenched edges, which break, 16.7 % with tempered ones): a straight hard band along the load necks first, as in §15.7. Smaller angles keep the gain: 24.7, 31.5 and 33.3 % at 50, 55 and 57° (675, 640 and 631 MPa; 149, 185 and 194 MJ/m³). At 57° the dog-bone is 14 % stronger than the untreated sheet, with 24 % more uniform elongation and 44 % more energy, against 23.0 % for the corrugated tracks of §15.7 in the same dog-bone: the edges move the drop to smaller angles, and an angle a few degrees below θ* keeps a specimen on the safe side. The gain holds on a gauge of 180 mm (31.4 % at 57°) and at 58° (32.7 %); in a dog-bone twice as wide (88 mm), where the edges weigh half as much, the drop moves back towards θ*: 34.6 %, 622 MPa, 200 MJ/m³ at 60°, 35.2 %, 643 MPa, 208 MJ/m³ at 57°. The as-quenched martensite, which the ductile rule spares, breaks in the dog-bone: 24.4 % at 57° (627 MPa, 138 MJ/m³, the strength at the energy of the untreated sheet; 15.0 % at 55°); tempered (c = 3), 27.3 %, 601 MPa, 151 MJ/m³. Away from the edges the network resists the localized neck: under uniaxial stress (--study uniaxial, the groove in the long cell, the shear free) the least limits are 0.514 at ±60° and 0.489 at ±55°, against 0.365 for the untreated sheet, 0.371 for the corrugation (H/P 0.25) and 0.344 for straight tracks at 45°.

17.5 Crossed families on the drawing side. Under the paths of forming (the principal axes held), the least limits over the grooves:

design, 24 %

ρ = −½

−¼

untreated sheet

0.362

0.253

crossed at ±45°

0.343

0.224

±55°

0.420

0.233

±60°

0.449

0.235

±65°

0.499

0.256

±70°

0.357

0.209

Each inclined neck runs near one family but crosses the other at a large angle, which stops it: in uniaxial tension the networks beyond φ0 raise the forming limit (by 16, 24 and 38 % at ±55, ±60 and ±65°); at ±70° the families lie near the direction of the critical neck, which runs along one of them (a groove at 20°: 0.357). At ρ = −¼, whose φ0 is 63.4°, the networks at most match the untreated sheet (0.256 at ±65°): the gain is confined to the neighbourhood of uniaxial tension. The whole drawing side (ρ = −⅜, −⅛ and 0 added) locates its end: the gain vanishes near the path whose line of zero extension reaches the families, ρ = −cot² θ, between −⅜ and −¼ at ±60° (−⅓) and near −¼ at ±65° (−0.22; +26 % at −⅜, +1 % at −¼, −18 % at −⅛); the network at ±55° keeps +6 % at −⅜, beyond its bound (−0.49). In plane strain all networks lie below the untreated sheet (0.147 to 0.151 against 0.195). Freeing the shear does not save single families: straight tracks reach at most 0.350 (45°) against 0.362.

A check of the rule on corrugations: θ* places the flanks at H/P = 0.270, but the uniform elongation peaks at 0.25 and declines slowly beyond (30.2, 30.1, 29.7 and 28.8 % at 0.25, 0.26, 0.27 and 0.28, 27.5 % at 0.3; examples/laser_corrugation_fine.py): the crests, which must bend before the flanks carry load, favour a slightly earlier locking, and the rule gives the order of the optimum, not its exact height. The snapshots of the cell (examples/laser_cell_fields.py) show the two mechanisms: the matrix strains in bands along the flanks of corrugated tracks, uniformly inside the rhombic cells of the network, which holds the width of the sheet before it locks (a lateral contraction of 3.8 % at 10 % of strain against 4.7 % for the matrix alone, 15.3 % at 40 % against 15.5 %).

17.6 What it means. On the drawing side as on the stretching side, single families of tracks, straight or corrugated, do not raise the forming limit: the inclined necks find their way along them. The rule selects a better architecture than the corrugation: two families of straight tracks crossed just beyond the line of zero extension, a scissor network that locks at an angle given in closed form; it hardens the sheet late in uniaxial tension without bending its tracks, spares the as-quenched martensite, raises the forming limit of the drawing side near uniaxial tension, and keeps its gain in a dog-bone at an angle a few degrees below θ*. The free edges are its weak points, and those of every architecture: the gains of the sheet belong to closed sections (tubes, where the network runs as two helices) and to parts wider than their loaded zone.

the forming limits of the drawing side for single families and crossed families against the untreated sheet and the classical analysis; the limit against the angle of the groove in uniaxial tension; the uniform elongation of crossed families against their half-angle in the periodic sheet and in dog-bones; the plastic strain of a dog-bone of crossed tracks necking at its free edges

17.7 The treated fraction, full treatment and switched phases (examples/laser_fraction_inverse.py). Crossed families of 6 to 60 % treated, each over 45 to 65°, periodic sheet, shear free:

treated

best θ

ductile: R_m / A_g / energy

as-quenched: best A_g (or failure)

6 %

60°

562 / 31.5 / 164

31.5

12 %

60°

574 / 33.7 / 180

33.7

18 %

60°

588 / 37.2 / 204

37.2

24 %

60°

606 / 42.9 / 245

39.2

30 %

60°

623 / 46.5 / 276

36.8

36 %

57.5°

687 / 37.7 / 245

29.9

48 %

55°

757 / 38.3 / 276

26.2

60 %

50°

931 / 23.9 / 207

17.1

The optimum lies between 24 and 30 % (30 % ductile, 24 % as-quenched, the martensite of denser networks breaking first); the best angle stays at 60°, near θ*, up to 30 %, then falls (a dense network locks later than thin inextensible tracks). Full treatment is not a solution: the homogeneous sheets, one laser state over the whole sheet, run from 552 MPa and 26.8 % (untreated) to 1558 MPa and 7.0 % (martensite), their product R_m A_g at most 15.2 GPa % (26.0 for the network at 24 %, 29.0 at 30 %); at equal strength (606 MPa) a homogeneous sheet reaches 24.9 %, the network 42.9 %. Switching the phases (annealed tracks, 24 %, in a martensite matrix) destroys the effect: straight soft tracks along the load keep 1292 MPa but neck at 8.5 %, crossed soft tracks at ±55 to ±65° neck at 5.0 to 6.4 % (617 to 636 MPa), the soft network carrying all the strain near the line of zero extension, at ±45° at 15.5 %. The hard phase must form the mechanism, the soft phase fill its cells.

References

  • Wang Z. (2022) Architecturation de tôles métalliques par traitement laser localisé. PhD thesis, HESAM Université (ENSAM, PIMM), supervised by J. Dirrenberger. tel-04041478.

  • Wang Z., Dirrenberger J., Lapouge P., Dubent S. (2022) Laser treatment of 430 ferritic stainless steel for enhanced mechanical properties. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 831, 142205. 10.1016/j.msea.2021.142205

  • Wang Z., Dirrenberger J., Lapouge P., Dubent S., Jabir H., Michel V. (2022) Microstructure evolution and mechanical properties of AISI 430 ferritic stainless steel strengthened through laser carburization. J. Eng. Mater. Technol. 144, 041005. 10.1115/1.4055025

  • Wang Z., Bouaziz O., Dirrenberger J., Lapouge P. (2023) Corrugation reinforced architectured materials by direct laser hardening: a study of geometrically induced work hardening in steel. steel res. int. 94, 2200695. 10.1002/srin.202200695

  • Lapouge P., Dirrenberger J., Coste F., Schneider M. (2019) Laser heat treatment of martensitic steel and dual-phase steel with high martensite content. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 752, 128–135. 10.1016/j.msea.2019.03.016

  • Bouaziz O., Bréchet Y., Embury J.D. (2008) Heterogeneous and architectured materials: a possible strategy for design of structural materials. Adv. Eng. Mater. 10, 24–36. 10.1002/adem.200700289

  • Brechet Y., Embury J.D. (2013) Architectured materials: expanding materials space. Scripta Mater. 68, 1–3. 10.1016/j.scriptamat.2012.07.038

  • Bouaziz O. (2013) Geometrically induced strain hardening. Scripta Mater. 68, 28–30. 10.1016/j.scriptamat.2012.08.008

  • Fraser M., Zurob H., Wu P., Bouaziz O. (2014) Analytical model of the unbending behavior of corrugated reinforcements. Adv. Eng. Mater. 16, 872–877. 10.1002/adem.201300525

  • Fraser M., Zurob H.S., Wu P. (2018a) Corrugation reinforced composites: a method for filling holes in material-property space. Adv. Eng. Mater. 20, 1700834. 10.1002/adem.201700834

  • Fraser M., Zurob H.S., Wu P. (2018b) Comparing the effect of geometry on the stress-strain response of isolated corrugation structures and corrugation reinforced composite structures. Compos. Struct. 187, 308–315. 10.1016/j.compstruct.2017.12.076

  • Fraser M., Zurob H., Wu P., Bouaziz O. (2020) Increasing necking strain through corrugation: identifying composite systems that can benefit from corrugated geometry. Materials 13, 5175. 10.3390/ma13225175

  • Hill R. (1952) On discontinuous plastic states, with special reference to localized necking in thin sheets. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 1, 19–30. 10.1016/0022-5096(52)90003-3

  • Marciniak Z., Kuczyński K. (1967) Limit strains in the processes of stretch-forming sheet metal. Int. J. Mech. Sci. 9, 609–620. 10.1016/0020-7403(67)90066-5

  • Jang K.-I., Chung H.U., Xu S., et al. (2015) Soft network composite materials with deterministic and bio-inspired designs. Nat. Commun. 6, 6566. 10.1038/ncomms7566

  • Ma Q., Cheng H., Jang K.-I., et al. (2016) A nonlinear mechanics model of bio-inspired hierarchical lattice materials consisting of horseshoe microstructures. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 90, 179–202. 10.1016/j.jmps.2016.02.012

  • Embury D., Bouaziz O. (2010) Steel-based composites: driving forces and classifications. Annu. Rev. Mater. Res. 40, 213–241. 10.1146/annurev-matsci-070909-104438

  • Breukelman H.J., Santofimia M.J., Hidalgo J. (2022) Hierarchically patterned multiphase steels created by localised laser treatments. Mater. Des. 221, 110984. 10.1016/j.matdes.2022.110984

  • Rosenthal D. (1946) The theory of moving sources of heat and its application to metal treatments. Trans. ASME 68, 849–865. 10.1115/1.4018624

  • Cline H.E., Anthony T.R. (1977) Heat treating and melting material with a scanning laser or electron beam. J. Appl. Phys. 48, 3895–3900. 10.1063/1.324261

  • Ashby M.F., Easterling K.E. (1984) The transformation hardening of steel surfaces by laser beams—I. Hypo-eutectoid steels. Acta Metall. 32, 1935–1948. 10.1016/0001-6160(84)90175-5

  • Shercliff H.R., Ashby M.F. (1991) The prediction of case depth in laser transformation hardening. Metall. Trans. A 22, 2459–2466. 10.1007/BF02665012

  • Andrews K.W. (1965) Empirical formulae for the calculation of some transformation temperatures. J. Iron Steel Inst. 203, 721–727.

  • Koistinen D.P., Marburger R.E. (1959) A general equation prescribing the extent of the austenite-martensite transformation in pure iron-carbon alloys and plain carbon steels. Acta Metall. 7, 59–60. 10.1016/0001-6160(59)90170-1

  • Maynier P., Jungmann B., Dollet J. (1978) Creusot-Loire system for the prediction of the mechanical properties of low alloy steel products. In Hardenability Concepts with Applications to Steel, TMS-AIME, 518–545.

  • Hollomon J.H., Jaffe L.D. (1945) Time-temperature relations in tempering steel. Trans. AIME 162, 223–249.

  • Biro E. et al. (2013) Predicting transient softening in the sub-critical heat-affected zone of dual-phase and martensitic steel welds. ISIJ Int. 53, 110–118. 10.2355/isijinternational.53.110

  • Pavlina E.J., Van Tyne C.J. (2008) Correlation of yield strength and tensile strength with hardness for steels. J. Mater. Eng. Perform. 17, 888–893. 10.1007/s11665-008-9225-5

  • Katsamas A.I., Haidemenopoulos G.N. (2001) Laser-beam carburizing of low-alloy steels. Surf. Coat. Technol. 139, 183–191. 10.1016/S0257-8972(00)01061-6

  • Schaaf P. (2002) Laser nitriding of metals. Prog. Mater. Sci. 47, 1–161. 10.1016/S0079-6425(00)00003-7

  • Simo J.C., Hughes T.J.R. (1998) Computational Inelasticity. Springer. 10.1007/b98904

  • Jones D.R., Schonlau M., Welch W.J. (1998) Efficient global optimization of expensive black-box functions. J. Global Optim. 13, 455–492. 10.1023/A:1008306431147

  • Tovar A., Patel N.M., Niebur G.L., Sen M., Renaud J.E. (2006) Topology optimization using a hybrid cellular automaton method with local control rules. J. Mech. Des. 128, 1205–1216. 10.1115/1.2336251

  • Nordin A. (2020) Comparison of three different heuristics for laser heat treatment pattern design. Proc. NordDesign 2020. 10.35199/NORDDESIGN2020.17

  • Jahn A. et al. (2011) Local laser strengthening of steel sheets for load adapted component design in car body structures. Phys. Procedia 12, 431–441. 10.1016/j.phpro.2011.03.054

  • Kim H.-g., Yoon J. (2021) Effect of laser patterning on axial crushing performance of cylindrical 22MnB5 tubes. Compos. Struct. 262, 113633. 10.1016/j.compstruct.2021.113633

Fracture, cellular automata and topology optimization (§5–§9):

  • Pijaudier-Cabot G., Bažant Z.P. (1987) Nonlocal damage theory. J. Eng. Mech. 113, 1512–1533. 10.1061/(ASCE)0733-9399(1987)113:10(1512)

  • de Geus T.W.J., Peerlings R.H.J., Geers M.G.D. (2015) Microstructural topology effects on the onset of ductile failure in multi-phase materials — a systematic computational approach. Int. J. Solids Struct. 67–68, 326–339. 10.1016/j.ijsolstr.2015.04.035

  • Fukatsu Y. et al. (2024) Mater. Today Commun. 41, 110360. 10.1016/j.mtcomm.2024.110360

  • Kim H.-g. et al. (2022) Materials 15, 6580. 10.3390/ma15196580

  • Piccininni A., Palumbo G. (2020) Design and optimization of the local laser treatment to improve the formability of age hardenable aluminium alloys. Materials 13, 1576. 10.3390/ma13071576

  • Kahrimanidis A., Lechner M., Degner J., Wortberg D., Merklein M. (2015) Process design of aluminum tailor heat treated blanks. Materials 8, 8524–8538. 10.3390/ma8125476

  • Werner M. (2019) Simulation-based design of laser-weld hardening patterns. NAFEMS conference on simulation-based optimisation, Berlin.

  • Kita E., Toyoda T. (2000) Structural design using cellular automata. Struct. Multidiscip. Optim. 19, 64–73. 10.1007/s001580050086

  • Hajela P., Kim B. (2001) On the use of energy minimization for CA based analysis in elasticity. Struct. Multidiscip. Optim. 23, 24–33. 10.1007/s00158-001-0162-2

  • Missoum S., Gürdal Z., Setoodeh S. (2005) Study of a new local update scheme for cellular automata in structural design. Struct. Multidiscip. Optim. 29, 103–112. 10.1007/s00158-004-0464-2

  • Abdalla M.M., Kim S., Gürdal Z. (2004) Multigrid accelerated cellular automata for structural design optimization: a 1-D implementation. AIAA 2004-1644. 10.2514/6.2004-1644

  • Zakhama R., Abdalla M.M., Smaoui H., Gürdal Z. (2009) Multigrid implementation of cellular automata for topology optimization of continuum structures. Comput. Model. Eng. Sci. 51, 1–25.

  • Patel N.M. (2007) Crashworthiness design using topology optimization. PhD thesis, University of Notre Dame.

  • Mozumder C.K. (2010) Topometry optimization of sheet metal structures for crashworthiness design using hybrid cellular automata. PhD thesis, University of Notre Dame.

  • Raeisi S., Tapkir P., Tovar A., Mozumder C., Xu S. (2019) Multi-material topology optimization for crashworthiness using hybrid cellular automata. SAE 2019-01-0826. 10.4271/2019-01-0826

  • Querin O.M., Steven G.P., Xie Y.M. (1998) Evolutionary structural optimisation (ESO) using a bidirectional algorithm. Eng. Comput. 15, 1031–1048. 10.1108/02644409810244129

  • Huang X., Xie Y.M. (2007) Convergent and mesh-independent solutions for the bi-directional evolutionary structural optimization method. Finite Elem. Anal. Des. 43, 1039–1049. 10.1016/j.finel.2007.06.006

  • Huang X., Xie Y.M. (2009) Bi-directional evolutionary topology optimization of continuum structures with one or multiple materials. Comput. Mech. 43, 393–401. 10.1007/s00466-008-0312-0

  • Huang X., Xie Y.M. (2010) Evolutionary Topology Optimization of Continuum Structures. Wiley. 10.1002/9780470689486

  • Bendsøe M.P. (1989) Optimal shape design as a material distribution problem. Struct. Optim. 1, 193–202. 10.1007/BF01650949

  • Bruns T.E., Tortorelli D.A. (2001) Topology optimization of non-linear elastic structures and compliant mechanisms. Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng. 190, 3443–3459. 10.1016/S0045-7825(00)00278-4

  • Wang F., Lazarov B.S., Sigmund O. (2011) On projection methods, convergence and robust formulations in topology optimization. Struct. Multidiscip. Optim. 43, 767–784. 10.1007/s00158-010-0602-y

  • Svanberg K. (1987) The method of moving asymptotes — a new method for structural optimization. Int. J. Numer. Methods Eng. 24, 359–373. 10.1002/nme.1620240207

  • Amir O. (2017) Stress-constrained continuum topology optimization: a new approach based on elasto-plasticity. Struct. Multidiscip. Optim. 55, 1797–1818. 10.1007/s00158-016-1618-8

  • Alberdi R., Khandelwal K. (2019) Finite Elem. Anal. Des. 164, 18–41. 10.1016/j.finel.2019.06.003; (2020) Int. J. Solids Struct. 193–194, 152–171. 10.1016/j.ijsolstr.2020.02.006

  • Alberdi R., Zhang G., Li L., Khandelwal K. (2018) A unified framework for nonlinear path-dependent sensitivity analysis in topology optimization. Int. J. Numer. Methods Eng. 115, 1–56. 10.1002/nme.5794

  • Abueidda D.W., Kang Z., Koric S., James K.A., Jasiuk I.M. (2021) Topology optimization for three-dimensional elastoplastic architected materials using a path-dependent adjoint method. Int. J. Numer. Methods Eng. 122, 1889–1910. 10.1002/nme.6604

  • Wallin M., Jönsson V., Wingren E. (2016) Topology optimization based on finite strain plasticity. Struct. Multidiscip. Optim. 54, 783–793. 10.1007/s00158-016-1435-0

  • Michaleris P., Tortorelli D.A., Vidal C.A. (1994) Tangent operators and design sensitivity formulations for transient non-linear coupled problems with applications to elastoplasticity. Int. J. Numer. Methods Eng. 37, 2471–2499. 10.1002/nme.1620371408

Load cases and alternative materials (§10–§11):

  • Saxena A., Hudak S.J. (1978) Review and extension of compliance information for common crack growth specimens. Int. J. Fract. 14, 453–468. 10.1007/BF01390468

  • Simha N.K., Fischer F.D., Kolednik O., Chen C.R. (2003) Inhomogeneity effects on the crack driving force in elastic and elastic–plastic materials. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 51, 209–240. 10.1016/S0022-5096(02)00025-X

  • Simha N.K., Fischer F.D., Kolednik O., Predan J., Shan G.X. (2005) Crack tip shielding or anti-shielding due to smooth and discontinuous material inhomogeneities. Int. J. Fract. 135, 73–93. 10.1007/s10704-005-3944-5

  • Kolednik O., Predan J., Fischer F.D., Fratzl P. (2011) Bioinspired design criteria for damage-resistant materials with periodically varying microstructure. Adv. Funct. Mater. 21, 3634–3641. 10.1002/adfm.201100443

  • Sistaninia M., Kolednik O. (2014) Effect of a single soft interlayer on the crack driving force. Eng. Fract. Mech. 130, 21–41.

  • Hill R. (1948) A theory of the yielding and plastic flow of anisotropic metals. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 193, 281–297. 10.1098/rspa.1948.0045

  • Lankford W.T., Snyder S.C., Bauscher J.A. (1950) New criteria for predicting the press performance of deep drawing sheets. Trans. ASM 42, 1197–1232.

  • Karbasian H., Tekkaya A.E. (2010) A review on hot stamping. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 210, 2103–2118. 10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2010.07.019

  • Myhr O.R., Grong Ø. (1991) Process modelling applied to 6082-T6 aluminium weldments — I. Reaction kinetics. Acta Metall. Mater. 39, 2693–2702. 10.1016/0956-7151(91)90085-F

  • Merklein M., Lechler J., Geiger M. (2006) Characterisation of the flow properties of the quenchenable ultra high strength steel 22MnB5. CIRP Ann. 55, 229–232. 10.1016/S0007-8506(07)60404-1

  • Neimitz A., Galkiewicz J., Lipiec S., Dzioba I. (2018) Estimation of the onset of crack growth in ductile materials. Materials 11, 2026. 10.3390/ma11102026

  • Ray R.K., Jonas J.J., Hook R.E. (1994) Cold rolling and annealing textures in low carbon and extra low carbon steels. Int. Mater. Rev. 39, 129–172. 10.1179/imr.1994.39.4.129

  • Ray R.K., Jonas J.J. (1990) Transformation textures in steels. Int. Mater. Rev. 35, 1–36. 10.1179/095066090790324046

  • Petrov R.H., Sidor J., Kestens L.A.I. (2012) Texture formation in high strength low alloy steel reheated with ultrafast heating rates. Mater. Sci. Forum 702–703, 798–801.

  • Barlat F., Brem J.C., Yoon J.W., Chung K., Dick R.E., Lege D.J., Pourboghrat F., Choi S.-H., Chu E. (2003) Plane stress yield function for aluminum alloy sheets — part 1: theory. Int. J. Plast. 19, 1297–1319.

  • Michel J.-C., Moulinec H., Suquet P. (1999) Effective properties of composite materials with periodic microstructure: a computational approach. Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng. 172, 109–143.

  • Hill R. (1963) Elastic properties of reinforced solids: some theoretical principles. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 11, 357–372.

  • Sistaninia M., Kolednik O. (2017) Improving strength and toughness of materials by utilizing spatial variations of the yield stress. Acta Mater. 122, 207–219.

  • Minami F., Toyoda M., Thaulow C., Hauge M. (1995) Effect of strength mis-match on fracture mechanical behavior of HAZ-notched weld joint. Q. J. Jpn. Weld. Soc. 13, 508–517. 10.2207/qjjws.13.508

  • Nègre P., Steglich D., Brocks W. (2005) Crack extension at an interface: prediction of fracture toughness and simulation of crack path deviation. Int. J. Fract. 134, 209–229. 10.1007/s10704-005-0523-8

  • Zhang M., Zhao N., Yu Q., et al. (2022) On the damage tolerance of 3-D printed Mg-Ti interpenetrating-phase composites with bioinspired architectures. Nat. Commun. 13, 3247. 10.1038/s41467-022-30873-9

  • Pandolfi A., Weinberg K., Ortiz M. (2021) A comparative accuracy and convergence study of eigenerosion and phase-field models of fracture. arXiv:2101.12520.

  • Kim S.A., Johnson W.L. (2007) Elastic constants and internal friction of martensitic steel, ferritic-pearlitic steel, and α-iron. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 452–453, 633–639.

  • Li J.-F., Soldatov I.V., Tang X.-C., et al. (2022) Metallic Mimosa pudica: a 3D biomimetic buckling structure made of metallic glasses. Sci. Adv. 8, eabm7658. 10.1126/sciadv.abm7658

  • da Costa et al. (2020) Stiffness and hardness gradients obtained by laser surface melting of an aged β-Ti alloy. Mater. Lett. 260, 126901. 10.1016/j.matlet.2019.126901

  • Khan M.I., Pequegnat A., Zhou Y.N. (2013) Multiple memory shape memory alloys. Adv. Eng. Mater. 15, 386–393. 10.1002/adem.201200246

  • Šittner P., Heller L., Pilch J., Curfs C., Alonso T., Favier D. (2014) Young’s modulus of austenite and martensite phases in superelastic NiTi wires. J. Mater. Eng. Perform. 23, 2303–2314. 10.1007/s11665-014-0976-x

  • Meng Q., Liu Y., Yang H., Shariat B.S., Nam T.-H. (2012) Functionally graded NiTi strips prepared by laser surface anneal. Acta Mater. 60, 1658–1668. 10.1016/j.actamat.2011.11.052

  • Garcia-Llamas E., Pujante J., Frómeta D., et al. (2023) Optimization of thick 22MnB5 sheet steel part performance through laser tempering. Metals 13, 396. 10.3390/met13020396

  • Somani M.C., Juntunen P., Karjalainen L.P., Misra R.D.K., Kyröläinen A. (2009) Enhanced mechanical properties through reversion in metastable austenitic stainless steels. Metall. Mater. Trans. A 40, 729–744. 10.1007/s11661-008-9723-y

  • Järvenpää A., Jaskari M., Kisko A., Karjalainen P. (2020) Processing and properties of reversion-treated austenitic stainless steels. Metals 10, 281. 10.3390/met10020281

  • Leskovšek V., Godec M., Kogej P. (2016) Influence of low-temperature nitriding on the strain-induced martensite and laser-quenched austenite in a magnetic encoder made from 304L stainless steel. Sci. Rep. 6, 30979. 10.1038/srep30979

  • Kashaev N., Groth A., Ventzke V., Horstmann M., Riekehr S., Staron P., Huber N. (2021) Effect of laser heating on mechanical properties, residual stresses and retardation of fatigue crack growth in AA2024. Fatigue Fract. Eng. Mater. Struct. 44, 887–900. 10.1111/ffe.13400